Linked by Matthias Breiter on Thu 14th Apr 2005 20:23 UTC
OSNews, Generic OSes I just want to show you a great add-on for DOS, called DESKWORK. It's an operating system build upon DOS, just like older Windows versions were build upon DOS. It has been written by Konstantin Koll for several years now, who founded a small company called Mystic Bytes to produce DESKWORK.
Order by: Score:

v ???
by Chris on Thu 14th Apr 2005 20:34 UTC
Might have been a nice product ten year ago
by walterbyrd on Thu 14th Apr 2005 20:49 UTC

Actually, 15 years ago might be more realistic.

I see no point in this today.

Does it have a TCP/IP stack? Will it connect to the internet? If not, then it isn't of much value.

Awesome
by P on Thu 14th Apr 2005 20:56 UTC

There's always a point to anything that is done, otherwise it wouldnt be done. Plus, DOs still has its niche.

Now, for the thing itself.. I don't know if I'll use it, but it's great that _someone_ is trying out "metadata only" filesystem without folders. We'll at least get to find out if it's a workable solution!

TCP/IP
by MattPie on Thu 14th Apr 2005 21:00 UTC

Does it have a TCP/IP stack? Will it connect to the internet? If not, then it isn't of much value.

At some point, Linux and Windows didn't have a TCP/IP stack either. That being said, I tend to agree with you. Other than futzing with with a really old computer, there doesn't seem to be much use for this, IMHO. I don't read German, so maybe there's some fantastic usabilty gems hiding in there...

Re: Might have been a nice product ten year ago
by Big Moron on Thu 14th Apr 2005 21:02 UTC

"Does it have a TCP/IP stack? Will it connect to the internet? If not, then it isn't of much value."

You didn't read it all... he said it did not have such support yet... so you comment is a bit of oximorones...

"I see no point in this today."

Well, for most that is so true... for the ones that use DOS like OS's... well, it will be, at least to see what it is all about...

It is for those interested...

Mein gott...
by Best on Thu 14th Apr 2005 21:07 UTC

Its LCARS.

Might work out nicely for devices with limited displays, interfaces, and most of all limited power.

Re: Mein gott...
by Tony Scilingo on Thu 14th Apr 2005 21:11 UTC

I was just about to say the same thing! It looks a lot like LCARS...they must be fans of Star Trek...

love the trek aspect :)
by mini-me on Thu 14th Apr 2005 21:17 UTC

just love it!

v Morons
by adapt on Thu 14th Apr 2005 21:18 UTC
re: Morons
by P on Thu 14th Apr 2005 21:27 UTC

Well said. I'm sick of these comments too, but I just ignore them rather than keep it alive by replying. Unfortunately, in the case of many trolls, they thrive on angry replies, and the only way to really get rid of them is for everyone to ignore - which is hard to accomplish in a free forum like the internet.

@adapt
by Chris on Thu 14th Apr 2005 21:36 UTC

Mod-up parent... Mod that to an article on the main page, with all the swearing please ;) . Then start kicking people for posting stupid things about projects.

I'm with you adam, you're exactly right!

I like the pink sock comment, but I don't understand what it means? Pinko?

cool
by broken windows on Thu 14th Apr 2005 21:43 UTC

i too think this is a cool project. who cares if 99.9% of the world never use it and 99% of the world never use it. its one mans project, nuthing more. side note: isnt that how linux started?

Pink Sock
by adapt on Thu 14th Apr 2005 21:44 UTC

A Pink Sock is probably the most disgusting thing in human history. I'll refrain from explaining. It's putrid. A little google search will help you find it if you want. You've been warned though!

-adam

oops
by broken windows on Thu 14th Apr 2005 21:45 UTC

i meant 99% of the world hav never heard of it

Kudos to the devs!!!!
by jay_of_today on Thu 14th Apr 2005 21:47 UTC

Yeah, I like it the way it is. This shows why things sucks today, with all that pseudo-3D GPU and 3 HT UltraPower CPUs on the market running those crappy pseudo-modern OS. AMIGA-OS was a modernOS ten years ago using a couple of Mhz right in your face! go figure it out!
Anyway, I think theres still a niche for that kind of systems. Now, you must implement the tcp/ip stack.


Gutten Glück mein freunde :-)
jay

Wow!
by Anonymous on Thu 14th Apr 2005 22:11 UTC

I love the Star Trek theme its got going!

cool :)
by Sigfrodi on Thu 14th Apr 2005 22:30 UTC

I like it, that's a nice project ;) I'll try it on my good old 486. I hope there will be an english version ;)

Keep up the good work ;)

awesome
by Anonymous on Thu 14th Apr 2005 22:52 UTC

this is what hobby OSes are about.
finally an OS that uses the same organization system as me.

Interesting...
by Morgan on Thu 14th Apr 2005 23:13 UTC

I like the look of this project. I don't speak German at all, but still, it will be fun to play around with.

I wonder if it will run under DosBox? The author said it works with MS-DOS and DRDOS, and I've never had an issue running anything under DosBox before. I wouldn't need TCP/IP; I could download anything I needed using the host OS (Linux) to a DosBox-mounted directory.

With an English translation, I could even see using this to set up a kid-friendly computer, especially for a kid that enjoys watching Star Trek!

Also, I just checked out the German website, translated by Babelfish. There's a very detailed page on connecting a Siemens S65 cellphone to the system. This is very interesting to me; my cellphone is a Siemens S56, which from what I can tell is a very similar phone. I use Infrared (and soon Bluetooth when I get my iBook), but all I can do right now is send MIDI ringtones and pictures to the phone, and go online with my PDA. It looks like the Deskworks software gives you full control over the phone. That's something I've been wanting to play around with for a while!

It's great to see UI innovation
by Charlie on Fri 15th Apr 2005 00:51 UTC

And it's great to see an alternative operating system thriving. DOS is still alive in the various free software variants, and it's certainly plausibly that with a project like this it could become a viable platform for niche areas and enthusiasts.

irony
by P on Fri 15th Apr 2005 01:05 UTC

lol does anyone else see the irony of DESKWORK's philosophy (of no icons, eye candy, etc) vs the website's aqua-like theme? ;)

Not LCARS
by Max on Fri 15th Apr 2005 01:08 UTC

this is LCARS:

http://www.telcomax.info/dans-software-germany/bilder/screens/les.j...

An Editor and a Media Player are available in this design and yes they both display the current stardate ;)

To the people that lives in a bottle...
by gbonvehi on Fri 15th Apr 2005 01:27 UTC

Just for the people in the 1st world that doesn't know this. There is people using 386 machines or still using Amiga, and most of them can't afford an upgrade like you. Also, there's another DOS, http://freedos.org which I guess could be used to run DESKWORK.

interesting gui method
by Robocoastie on Fri 15th Apr 2005 01:41 UTC

interesting gui. anything to get away from the blasted mouse! That is one of the worst inventions ever made and is single handedly responsible for a myriad of carpal tunnel cases.

another one
by Anonymous on Fri 15th Apr 2005 01:44 UTC

This one is better imho

http://www.pldos.pl/windos/screen.htm

RE:LCARS
by Michael Moran on Fri 15th Apr 2005 02:01 UTC

I always suspected the Enterprise ran DOS ;)

Seriously, it looks pretty interesting. Since its built on DOS that means its a program, right? I wonder how hard it would be to port it to linux? Could be a very interesting project.

-Mike

DOS and digital cameras...
by mopar on Fri 15th Apr 2005 02:34 UTC

It looked like it was maybe connected to a Sony Cybershot in one of the screenshots. In DOS? Very cool. I'm putting together an AMD 486DX/100 in a couple of weeks for my old games. Might be worth a try.

well
by Anonymous on Fri 15th Apr 2005 02:59 UTC

well tossed on a little 200 mb FAT32 partition and it installed and ran through XP no issue, no need to restart or anything just click on instal, type W, select your drive and then hit enter a couple of times, although the german makes taking advantage of the meta data difficult without a good deal more trial and error, it played a CD fine though so it is working. nifty. just thought i'd post to say that it works under XP.

Failed in dosbox .63 on BeOS
by cramit on Fri 15th Apr 2005 04:13 UTC

When I typed setup it filled the window with light-blue stripes. I don't know if it is a setup error with dosbox, because this is he first time I have used the program.

Any ideas would be nice (my german is not even close to good enough for the forums); seems like a cool litle operating enviroment (I guess that would be the right term?)

~Cramit

THere are better GUI's out there.
by XDelusion on Fri 15th Apr 2005 04:48 UTC

I've seen better GUI's for DOS, and no, Winblows is not one of them. ;)

Infact there are some out there that look and act a lot like Win95, but are only a few k in size. Kinda reminds me of the Amiga days once again, it is a shame no one knows anything about conserving resources anymore.

what liecense
by Aditya on Fri 15th Apr 2005 04:54 UTC

just curious under what liecence it is released?

nice work BTW ;)

i dig it
by natefrogg on Fri 15th Apr 2005 04:58 UTC

i really dig the interface, minimalist lcars aproach, i think it's really cool

man, it'd be cool to have a shell for nt based windows systems like this...

thanks for posting this! i had not heard of this project before reading the article, i love hearing about small niche market operating systems like this

much kudos!!

just to set this straight
by l3v1 on Fri 15th Apr 2005 06:33 UTC

It's an operating system build upon DOS, just like older Windows versions were build upon DOS

Thus those versions were not operating systems, just as this DW is not one either.

Re: Morons
by mikados on Fri 15th Apr 2005 07:44 UTC

Did this guy say he is trying to dominate the world with his project? NO. Did he say that its a competitor to windows/mac/linux? NO.

There are videos on the Deskwork homepage ('Presse' -> 'TV'). In the third one Konstantin Koll sais that he sees himself as serious competitor of M$.

Genie und Wahnsinn ...

Why DOS?
by John Nilsson on Fri 15th Apr 2005 10:16 UTC

Although I don't understand german that well, I must say that the info on the site look impressive. I always thought that those hobby project laked good design backgound. This doesn't apparently.

Just take a look at the cleartype page. Now if every subsystem of all OSS projects was documented in that manner the world would be a better place =)

What I don't get however is why he picked dos as a platform. Surley all the great software availible for some of the more "alive" platformes would be usefull.

DosBox and FreeDOS
by Matthias Breiter on Fri 15th Apr 2005 15:13 UTC

As Konstantin mentioned in his forum, Deskwork doesn't run in DosBox or within FreeDOS due to some differences compared to MS-DOS. He explains why on his Page (German only). It has something to do with memory managing AFAIK (I'm not a DOS expert at all).

Keep up the good work
by twocents on Fri 15th Apr 2005 16:46 UTC

Coupled with the freedos propject, Deskwork looks like a very nice add-on.

If these guys can create the TCP and Network tools so that they can run outside of the Deskwork Framework, the flexibility alone would add alot of additional punch to DOS Environments.

DESKWORK
by Member of the World on Fri 15th Apr 2005 20:48 UTC

Hello, you can only use Deskwork under MS-DOS 6.22.

And why not learning german to use Deskwork ?

Iam german and i must learn English to understand this, too.

But iam can not understand perfectllay all was i read, spoken, and meaning of THIS Languages !!!

Greetings from a Member of this World.

tcp/ip...
by mmu_man on Fri 15th Apr 2005 22:15 UTC

Hmm this reminds me a bit of Contiki ;)
Btw, maybe the IP stack used in contiki might be interesting...
as for the drivers, there are already a huge set of drivers for DOS based apps (cynr or something... aka "packet drivers"). The DOS VNC viewer uses them for example.

Cool
by Ambuj varshney on Sat 16th Apr 2005 06:51 UTC

I think seal 3 years back was quiet good but could not attract developers for further development.
Further qube released by same person who developed seal was good.looked queit professional.
Had multitasking support 24bpp colour support,mp3 ,simple html browser
lacked good development to develop further.
anyways dos now is dead.maybe porting these projects on linux would help


DESKWORK
by Member of the World on Sat 16th Apr 2005 09:23 UTC

@ all

Ask the vendor of DESKWORK for an English version of it ...!?

Here you can mail it: http://www.deskwork.de/KONTAKT.HTM

Member of the World

lcars hehe
by Anonymous on Sat 16th Apr 2005 19:31 UTC

mabey they could use it in a startreck movie.