Linked by Thom Holwerda on Sun 30th Oct 2005 15:53 UTC
Windows The 2nd beta of Windows' new shell (Monad) has been released for use with the just released .NET 2.0. "The Windows 'Monad' Shell is a new interactive command-line and task-based scripting technology in Windows that enables administrators to more efficiently and securely automate and control system management tasks on both desktops and servers." Download for x64 and x86.
Order by: Score:
Anonymous
Member since:
---

THe second biggest weakness of Windows, IMHO behind security is the horrible command.com. That really needs to be overhauled. If there's one thing I miss about Linux in Windows is the shell.

Reply Score: 0

n4cer Member since:
2005-07-06

Potential use for virus writers was not why it was pulled from Vista. The ship schedule/dependancy reset had more to do with it. There'll be multiple versions of Monad shipping out of band with Windows as they build up functionality. v1 is just the start (IIRC, 3 major releases are planned currently before it settles down a bit). Monad's only major dependancy is the .NET Framework, and it will likely be supported on XP/Server 2003 in addition to Vista, but Vista isn't the ship vehicle for it. It'll be included with the next version of Exchange and at least one of the other server products, and it's currently available as a seperate download and as part of the WinFX SDK.

Reply Score: 2

n4cer Member since:
2005-07-06

I should add that Monad could still be included with Vista. A final decision has not yet been made according to the most recent public info.

Also, the other server product it's shipping with besides Exchange is Microsoft Operations Manager (MOM).

Reply Score: 1

Anonymous Member since:
---

I agree. I have to use Windows at work. cmd.exe is awful. I know I can use Cygwin, but I wish I could just make bash my default shell.

Reply Score: 0

Anonymous Member since:
---

the shell for windows NT/2000/XP is cmd.exe not command.com

Reply Score: 1

v Didn't mention the GNU version...
by Anonymous on Sun 30th Oct 2005 21:04 UTC
gonad versus monad
by Anonymous on Sun 30th Oct 2005 23:21 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

I was wondering if someone was going to make the Gonad joke. If is kind of funny they named it Monad since it sounds so much like Gonad. Perhaps the MS Marketing boys are slipping.

Reply Score: 0

RE: gonad versus monad
by Anonymous on Mon 31st Oct 2005 16:28 UTC in reply to "gonad versus monad"
Anonymous Member since:
---

dude. monad is the beta name.. it's going to be called "MSH - microsoft shell"

Reply Score: 0

A good CLI is long due...
by Anonymous on Mon 31st Oct 2005 07:41 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

As others pointed out windows seriously need a GOOD command line environment. For the common user it means almost nothing, but for the admins who need to automate and script hundreds of clients it's a life saver.

And I know about most of the tricks of cmd.exe, of WSH, vbs and js, and WMI...

...even with Monad windows will still lack a practical set of utilities with command line interface: sure bash is a good shell, but without all the (dozens) of little unix filters/utils like grep, cut, cat, and so on it would be of little use.

Look on msdn how do you add a printer from the command line on windows... it's pretty ugly :-)

Reply Score: 0

woo hard:
by Nex6 on Mon 31st Oct 2005 16:08 UTC
Nex6
Member since:
2005-07-06

Option Explicit

Dim network

Set Network = CreateObject("Wscript.Network")
Network.AddWindowsPrinterConnection "\\server\share"

in a .vbs file,

that was hard


-Nex6

Edited 2005-10-31 16:09

Reply Score: 1

Does it support POSIX?
by Siffredi on Mon 31st Oct 2005 21:15 UTC
Siffredi
Member since:
2005-10-31

.

Reply Score: 1

RE: a good CLI is long due
by Anonymous on Mon 31st Oct 2005 22:20 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

even with Monad windows will still lack a practical set of utilities with command line interface: sure bash is a good shell, but without all the (dozens) of little unix filters/utils like grep, cut, cat, and so on it would be of little use.

Oh, please.. have you even looked at your Windows installation CD?

Look for Support tools, install it and you'll get about 100 command line utilities.

Then go to MSDN or Microsoft.com and download other similar packages: Resource Kit tools (another 180+ tools), IIS Admin kit tools, Administration Tools pack, Deploy tools, etc.

Trust me ;) , every aspect of administration and MUCH MORE is covered.

Microsoft provides, as you can see, *HUNDREDS* of command line utilities for Windows. They are not installed by default, I guess for the security reasons and the fact is, 99% of desktop users don't need them. Even administrators prefer to use GUI tools, don't ask why ;)

Sorry and I don't mean to trash you, but to say that Windows lacks command line utilities is just - ignorant.

Reply Score: 0

RE: A good CLI is long due...
by Azad Kupelian on Mon 31st Oct 2005 22:58 UTC
Azad Kupelian
Member since:
2005-10-04

The Unix command line tools such as grep, cut and cat are available for Windows.

You can download 118 of these that run on the Win32 subsystem at http://unxutils.sourceforge.net/.

More 300 that run on the Services for Unix subsystem come with Services for Unix. http://www.microsoft.com/sfu

Reply Score: 1