Linked by Andrew Youll on Tue 1st Nov 2005 18:32 UTC, submitted by Various Submitters
FreeBSD The new FreeBSD logo has finally been chosen, and can be seen here. The FreeBSD website will be updated shortly with the new logo in place of Beastie (on the website that is, not actually replacing Beastie as the mascot).
Order by: Score:
Very evil
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 18:42 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

But nice

Reply Score: 0

what's wrong with the beastie...:(
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 18:44 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

:(

Reply Score: 0

molnarcs Member since:
2005-09-10

Nothing. Beastie is the mascot - and it will remain so. This is a logo!

Reply Score: 5

FreeBSD Logo
by TaterSalad on Tue 1st Nov 2005 18:47 UTC
TaterSalad
Member since:
2005-07-06

Not bad, not bad at all. I think I like it. I would have liked it more if he put a face on it, but aside from that I still think its good.

Reply Score: 1

I like it
by mendicant on Tue 1st Nov 2005 18:52 UTC
mendicant
Member since:
2005-07-12

I really enjoy it. It's clean, it's simple, it's nice.

But doesn't it still embody some of the things they were trying to get away from with Beastie?

Reply Score: 1

RE: I like it
by Ronald Vos on Tue 1st Nov 2005 19:02 UTC in reply to "I like it"
Ronald Vos Member since:
2005-07-06

Actually, the FreeBSD community at large feels Beastie shouldn't be replaced, even if it scares away some people.

BTW, direct link:

http://logo-contest.freebsd.org.nyud.net:8090/result/640-1.png

Reply Score: 1

Alright!
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 18:52 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

Much more professional looking ;)
It was about time.

Reply Score: 0

Looks like...
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 18:52 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

...nothing. Pretty stupid to replace a funny very well known logo, it is. They relly should have kept Beastie.

Reply Score: 0

Beastie
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 18:53 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

Beastie will NOT BE REPLACED! Beastie is the mascot, not the logo, and he will be around forever.

Please remove the bullshit about Beastie being replaced from the text in the news.

Reply Score: 5

RE: Beastie
by Andrew Youll on Tue 1st Nov 2005 18:56 UTC in reply to "Beastie"
Andrew Youll Member since:
2005-06-29

From what I've read and heard, Beastie will be replaced on the actual site with the new Logo, this may not be the case in reality but a guy can only work with the tools he's given.

Reply Score: 5

RE[2]: Beastie
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 19:00 UTC in reply to "RE: Beastie"
Anonymous Member since:
---

Well, you should check your sources:
"Beastie will continue to represent the FreeBSD Project as our mascot. We won't kill Beastie. The closest logo-like thing that we have now is shown below, and we are looking for other options to be used like there. The new logo design may or may not include Beastie, or even a stylized representation. Again, Beastie is still alive!"

http://logo-contest.freebsd.org/

Reply Score: 2

Cool
by molnarcs on Tue 1st Nov 2005 18:55 UTC
molnarcs
Member since:
2005-09-10

This is cool! A very well thought out logo - the author was careful to take into consideration the possibilities of variations: on CD, shirts, boxes; customizations for various colors (see postcard theme here: http://logo-contest.freebsd.org/result/640-1.png ); customization themevize (see the security logo).

All in all: it sure took some time ;) - but the end result is satisfying. I like the crystal-look as well - we now have a cool kmenu button replacement ;) ))

Reply Score: 2

better link
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 19:06 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---
v When
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 19:14 UTC
RE: When
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 19:20 UTC in reply to "When"
Anonymous Member since:
---

http://dfe3300.karelia.ru/~ekostq/PUBLIC/OSREVIEW/osf_1b.jpg

I bet you want the good old days of X guis back ;)

Reply Score: 1

RE: When
by Devon on Tue 1st Nov 2005 19:21 UTC in reply to "When"
Devon Member since:
2005-06-30

--- "When will the sugary/candy/glass look finally go out of style?"

Take a look at the image that looks like a screenshot. There are plenty of style variations, you don't have to go with the crystal look.

Reply Score: 3

v How ugly
by Bascule on Tue 1st Nov 2005 19:18 UTC
Beastie
by Jedd on Tue 1st Nov 2005 19:38 UTC
Jedd
Member since:
2005-07-06

Not a bad logo, but the beastie is better. Long live the beastie!

Reply Score: 1

I will using Beastie
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 19:44 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

I will using Beastie, I'm free to do it :-), like the system.

The new logo looks like "piņata"


excuse my english, i'm spanish

Reply Score: 0

I prefer the older logo too
by atici on Tue 1st Nov 2005 19:46 UTC
atici
Member since:
2005-07-06

+1. Beastie logo was far better IMO. Likewise, former NetBSD logo was simply amazing. Those former logos had a lot of character and was cool in a retro way (just like the movie Tron is, or the game Darwinia is). Shiny well-curved logos might be trendy but lack in soul.

After all the logo is supposed to reflect the character of the FreeBSD project and the FreeBSD user -- not the user of the iCrap which looks shiny and does everything for you in a mediocre way.

Reply Score: 1

RE: I prefer the older logo too
by Celerate on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 00:18 UTC in reply to "I prefer the older logo too"
Celerate Member since:
2005-06-29

Marketing, which includes an ever changing logo is a major element of making a product popular; you may not like it, most people resent it when something they know are are comfortable with changes, but it happens eventually.

Things change just like people die, it's a fact of life even if it's not one you like. FWIW though I know what it feels like when something you like changes in a way you hate.

Reply Score: 1

logo
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 19:47 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

I don't really like this logo, it is bland and somewhat devil looking anyways for those who would be bothered by that. A good logo should be stylish and easy to draw with a pencil. This logo needs light shading to have any form at all--done 2-d it's just a plain circle with two coned horns, and no eyes--a beast blind to the world.

The best thing is, logos are not that important, FreeBSD will be as good as it was anyways, and if you like Beastie, you can use it for whatever you'd like, the image of beastie has not been banished.

Reply Score: 0

v Very cool
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 19:52 UTC
RE: Very cool
by h-milch-mann on Tue 1st Nov 2005 20:19 UTC in reply to "Very cool"
h-milch-mann Member since:
2005-10-27

Have you even looked briefly at the submission?
I bet not, else you'd seen that the designer submitted simpler and 2 color logos too.

Reply Score: 1

RE: Very cool
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 20:21 UTC in reply to "Very cool"
Anonymous Member since:
---

Monologos are already done, look at the picture posted earlier. Several variations of mono and two color there.

Reply Score: 0

Funny
by corentin on Tue 1st Nov 2005 20:01 UTC
corentin
Member since:
2005-08-08

It looks like a pokemon!

Reply Score: 1

Nope
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 20:12 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

I don't like it ;)

Reply Score: 0

Not Cool
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 20:28 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

First look, disappointed :-(

Reply Score: 0

Anonymous
Member since:
---

n/t

Reply Score: 0

The new logo
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 20:57 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

Looks like something suits might come up with! Beastie should poke this thing in the butt with his pitchfork!

Reply Score: 0

Beastie is the king
by Haicube on Tue 1st Nov 2005 20:59 UTC
Haicube
Member since:
2005-08-06

I love Beastie, anything else is worthless

Reply Score: 1

v Waste of Time
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 21:00 UTC
v RE: Waste of Time
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 21:12 UTC in reply to "Waste of Time"
RE[2]: Waste of Time
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 21:37 UTC in reply to "RE: Waste of Time"
Anonymous Member since:
---
RE[3]: Waste of Time
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 21:51 UTC in reply to "RE[2]: Waste of Time"
Anonymous Member since:
---

thats not bias at all, not in anyway.

Reply Score: 0

Logo Opinion - Bubble Gum Icky
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 21:04 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

I think they went for the lowest common denominator on this one, the logo lacks any sort of character. Its a balloon animal of some sort, and will look silly in the future when everyone has gotten over their "lets make it bubbly and shiny" phase.

Reply Score: 1

Might I comment...
by ValiantSoul on Tue 1st Nov 2005 21:09 UTC
ValiantSoul
Member since:
2005-07-20

NOOOOOOO

Oh well I've got lots of Beastie paraphernalia still

Reply Score: 1

Not very nice
by Joe User on Tue 1st Nov 2005 21:11 UTC
Joe User
Member since:
2005-06-29

I'm disappointed. It lacks personality, it looks like a face without eyes, nose and mouth...

Reply Score: 1

You can't satisfy all of the people ...
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 21:13 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

... all of the time. And I'm definintely unsatisfied.

The logo doesn't resemble much of anything, so it is not going to stick in my mind. Yes, yes. I know that it alludes to beastie's head. But it is far too abstract for my mind to make that reverse association.

Reply Score: 0

and now, for something quite similar
by Esaltato on Tue 1st Nov 2005 21:22 UTC
Esaltato
Member since:
2005-07-07

Ok it's not a ball; but it's very similar nonetheless.
For anyone who might be wondering, this is the logo of an italian singer, and it has been his previous band's logo from early nineties to around 2000.

http://images.google.it/images?q=cornucuore

Edited 2005-11-01 21:23

Reply Score: 1

Other challengers?
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 21:30 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

I would like to see the work of the runner-ups to this logo contest!

Reply Score: 0

hmm
by Miichael on Tue 1st Nov 2005 21:37 UTC
Miichael
Member since:
2005-10-14

when i first saw it.. reminded me too much of an all red firefox icon with devil horns
*shrug*

Reply Score: 1

IMO:
by Lazarus on Tue 1st Nov 2005 21:52 UTC
Lazarus
Member since:
2005-08-10

Yuck! Ugly new logo to go with thier ugly new web site (well, the web site isn't *that* bad)!

At least their software doesn't suck =D

</cankyoldmansramblings>

Reply Score: 1

RE: IMO:
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 02:27 UTC in reply to "IMO: "
Anonymous Member since:
---

agreet with you.

new web site sucks!!!
new logo stinks...

is this where freebsd is heading to???

Reply Score: 0

Looks Like ...
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 22:13 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

It looks like a tomato with horns.

Reply Score: 2

Look out Tux....
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 22:19 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

...You're next!

Reply Score: 0

I quite like it, but..
by A30Guy on Tue 1st Nov 2005 22:19 UTC
A30Guy
Member since:
2005-07-06

It does look a bit like a randy bowling ball!

Reply Score: 1

v GOOD, but not it
by jaboua on Tue 1st Nov 2005 22:20 UTC
GOOD, but not it
by jaboua on Tue 1st Nov 2005 22:20 UTC
jaboua
Member since:
2005-09-08

It's a good logo, congrats designer, but I don't think this is it for freebsd. I would rather have some logo with beastie in it, as mentioned! However, this is something which would fit on a KDE menu more than entire beastie.

Reply Score: 1

RE: GOOD, but not it
by jziegler on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 00:02 UTC in reply to "GOOD, but not it"
jziegler Member since:
2005-07-14

The head and horns of Beastie are in the logo. How much more do you want? ;)

Reply Score: 1

RE[2]: GOOD, but not it
by jaboua on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 20:18 UTC in reply to "RE: GOOD, but not it"
jaboua Member since:
2005-09-08

The face ;)

Reply Score: 1

bummer
by natefrogg on Tue 1st Nov 2005 22:26 UTC
natefrogg
Member since:
2005-08-16

very bland and boring, a circle with 2 cones...*yawn*

Reply Score: 1

I dont like it.
by Adam A on Tue 1st Nov 2005 23:31 UTC
Adam A
Member since:
2005-07-07

Its too glossy, and I use KDE.

However, the ball and the horns represents the daemon nicely, but if it wasn't so glossy I would consider it a job well done.

Reply Score: 1

RE: I dont like it.
by Anonymous on Tue 1st Nov 2005 23:45 UTC in reply to "I dont like it."
Anonymous Member since:
---

"Its too glossy, and I use KDE. "

Lol

Reply Score: 0

great stuff
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 00:04 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

I love it! I love it! I want one of those t-shirts

Reply Score: 0

I for one..
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 00:07 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

Think that it looks good. Well done. From a branding perspective, it can go more places than Beastie. Beastie is, after all al MASCOT. This is a LOGO.

Reply Score: 0

childlike
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 00:08 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

this is he mandrake effect. it looks like a toy. an immature product. the old logo and the current website looks solid and professional.

this new logo makes it look like a gimmiky toy not to be trusted or used on production systems.

Reply Score: 0

democratic?
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 00:22 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

Personally I dont see anything wrong with the current FreeBSD "Beastie".
I find it very interesting that the winning design was chosen as a result of 62 votes, out of 181.
I wonder why FreeBSD allowed such a small electorate to determine such an important issue? I don't how many FreeBSD users there are in the world, but perhaps a more representative selection process would have been "better"?

Reply Score: 1

dumb and stupid
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 00:26 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

this is stupid and dumb, their website looks fine the way it is... the lil guy is funny and cute.

this is really dumb. the new logo really sucks

Reply Score: 0

Unacceptable!
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 00:28 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

Looks like Beastie hatching from an egg.

Reply Score: 0

GAG me with a glass egg!
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 01:46 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

Mac did the glass thing. Now everybody wants to do the glass thing. Let Mac have the glass thing. That's the only thing Mac has. Oh, and ipods. They can have them too.

Unfortunately, the beastie puts off religious nut jobs. So I understand that they needed to either replace the logo or try to to spook anyone out with the logo.

The best logo is debian, even though noone knows what it means.

Hopefully they have some other variations of logos available. Don't they know anything about screen printing? Red on red? Come on. I'm very disappointed.

I agree with the previous posting saying it makes the OS seem cheap.

Reply Score: 0

Not bad...
by wakeupneo on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 01:47 UTC
wakeupneo
Member since:
2005-07-06

..but personally, I prefer my submitted design....well, I'm probably a little biased ;)

Is it possible to look at the other finalists? Anyone know of a page?

Reply Score: 1

I like it
by Chezz on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 02:09 UTC
Chezz
Member since:
2005-07-11

I really like this logo. It's clean and sexy.

Reply Score: 1

very very disappointed.
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 02:24 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

it's so bad. it should not be used to present freebsd.
or does this new logo actually reflect the direction of future development/market strategy for freebsd???

again, very very disappointed.

Reply Score: 0

I know the secret meaning of it
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 05:03 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

I first looked at it for awhile and then I figured it out. It is a red cows udder. Yah, that's it, right?

Reply Score: 0

I like it
by stormloss on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 07:04 UTC
stormloss
Member since:
2005-08-03

It's horny just like me. ;)
very cool

Reply Score: 1

beastie
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 07:04 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

I like the beastie better.This new logo looks like a virus.

Reply Score: 0

LOL
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 07:44 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

Well read all the comments and 60 something in people can still not see the difference from a logo and a mascot.
I think the new logo and great and as ever I love beastie as the mascot ;)

Get a clue before posting people.

LOL

Reply Score: 0

RE: LOL
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 08:47 UTC in reply to "LOL"
Anonymous Member since:
---

What says a mascot can't be part of a logo? Maybe you should have a look at this:
http://www.michelin.com/portail/home/home.jsp

Now, who should get a clue, brainiac?

And btw, I agree with the majority; This lame attempt at logo really sucks. "iBall with cones poised as horns" Seriously, WTF?

Reply Score: 0

Aw no
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 07:59 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

This one looks awful, like bubbly childrens' stuff.

What was wrong with the old one anyway??

Reply Score: 0

v DIGG.com
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 10:04 UTC
About the OLD logo
by Chreo on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 11:47 UTC
Chreo
Member since:
2005-07-06

Please people get this into your heads. THERE WAS NOT AN "OLD" LOGO. There is a mascot and his hame is Beastie and he shall reign over the animal kingdom of mascots ;D

In short, this is the FIRST and ONLY logo the freebsd project has ever had! As such it is very nice as it also gives the nod to the mascot.

Beastie will remain. I'm honestly surprised about the amount of people that apparently is illiterate and unable to read properly.

Reply Score: 1

RE: About the OLD logo
by wakeupneo on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 11:59 UTC in reply to "About the OLD logo"
wakeupneo Member since:
2005-07-06

"I'm honestly surprised about the amount of people that apparently is[/i] illiterate and unable to read properly."

Hmm...something about "glass houses" comes to mind ;)

Reply Score: 1

Logo...Who cares! Its the OS baby!
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 13:48 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

Who cares of the logo or mascot!

Seriously, the only thing that turns me on (besides
attractive women), is FreeBSD itself.

Not the mascot or the logo!
(I'm still wondering how a pair of cones and a sphere
can be considered sexy...Reminds me of Madonna and her
"missile cones" outfit!).

Reply Score: 0

nice to read
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 14:58 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

So different opinions. I, as for participant of the contest, think that community had to make an open election of the new logo. And to make more ads for this event to attact attention of more people and more designers.

Thanks,
Anton Gural

Reply Score: 0

Looks like a marshmellow cereal bit
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 15:49 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

I could weave better with my anus and a pair of chopsticks

They should've just used beastie's face rather than something which looks like it's part of a Pokemon breakfast cereal product.

Reply Score: 0

OH SHUT THE F*** UP
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 16:27 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

This logo will not affect FreeBSD's power to serve in any way so stop the CRYing. Thank you.

Reply Score: 0

red daemon is much better
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 16:28 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

Too bad ;) . I love the red daemon....

Reply Score: 0

Logo vs Mascot
by atici on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 16:34 UTC
atici
Member since:
2005-07-06

The claim that FreeBSD did not originally have a logo is simply ridiculous. It is the mascot vs. logo posts which have no clue. Why do you think people showed such a uniform reaction to this new so-called logo on this thread? Because FreeBSD has always had a logo with the beastie mascot in it. Even if it has not officially been called so, it was there and was far smarter snd cooler looking than this new travesty of a logo.

Reply Score: 1

Good changes
by Anonymous on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 16:39 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

I like alot the new logo and the new web. This change was needed.

Reply Score: 0

Reminded me instantly of this
by Buck on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 17:23 UTC
Buck
Member since:
2005-06-29

http://www.tokyoplastic.com/ (the 'opera dude' on the front page) also featured here http://www.tokyoplastic.com/musicbox.html

Almost just as combustible!

Reply Score: 1

mramirez
Member since:
2005-10-05

I remember the contest annoucement some time ago,
and If my memory doesn't fail, there were 2 reasons for a new logo.

The "Bestie" logo and "pet" was a comic, and wasn't considered enough "serious". FreeBSD community
intended to promote FreeBSD in companies and the corporate world (means "jobs" for you "hackers" !!!),
not just "Geeks" and universities.

This logo ("Bestie") was inspired in the "daemons", resident programs in *nix,
similar to the windoze services. (ok, ok, you *BSD guys, "daemons" are not "demons" !!!)

In marketing research, in order to promote a product or service, it is suggested not to use religion related concepts because there can be "conflicts" or hurt personal beliefs of the people to which is intended to sell the product.

Even that the "litle devil", I mean "daemon", may look innocent, some people may think not.

Personally speaking, I believe the new logo DIDN'T FULLFILL that 2 requirements. It's not enough
interesting for the "corporte world", and still is a "little devil", I mean a "little daemon",
in 3D and stylized...

I saw the annoucement some time ago, I was thinking in participate, and forgot, due to workload
:-(

Never tried FreeBSD, maybe I should... ;-)

What do you think ?

mramirez (a.t.) star (m.i.n.u.s.) dev (d.o.t.) com

Reply Score: 1

Anonymous Member since:
---

Ok.. The term daemon came from demon. In the very early UNIX days they called the background "helper" processes demons. This article eplains it a little bit (http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=daemon). Why is FreeBSD's mascot a little demon looking guy? Because he represents a daemon and his pitch-fork represents process forking. This has been discussed too many times. It is not evil in any way, shape or form. Beastie lives! Now, as for that colorful little butterfly, that is pure evil! Beastie and Tux will take care of that.

Reply Score: 0

to mrramires
by krispo on Wed 2nd Nov 2005 18:24 UTC
krispo
Member since:
2005-11-02

Creating this logo, I did it how i like. I like beastie (buy the way, there were no beastie images in in finalists works). I just want to help the FreeBSd community. Wait a year, and you will see, that people likes this logo. This fun and candystyled logo ;) Even nerds.

I have plans to make whole new look to all freebsd related ideas.

All materials are coming soon at http://freebsdlogo.org

Thanks,
anton_gural (at) freebsdlogo (dot) org

Reply Score: 1

Cutting logo
by tyuu on Thu 3rd Nov 2005 00:57 UTC
tyuu
Member since:
2005-11-03
indifferent
by Anonymous on Fri 4th Nov 2005 13:53 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

i guess a retail box will now blend in nicely next to something like mandrake n suse or whatever other distro. Personaly I would have just gone with the text in that font and kept the "nubby ball" out. The name in that typesetting is just fine. It's identifiable enough on its own. Beastie, AS THE MASCOT, will always be around of course, but replacing it on the wesite with the nubby ball...eeeesh. If you trying to market it as yet another windows replacement... well, I dont want to go off on a rant.

Reply Score: 0