Linked by Thom Holwerda on Fri 9th May 2008 21:46 UTC
In the News Multitouch has more or less turned into a buzzword these days - sometimes, its implementation makes sense and comes out as pretty useful (see the iPhone and Microsoft's Surface), however, other implementations turn out be debatable. There is another implementation out there, one that received a lot less attention from the press than the aforementioned cases: Jeff Han's Perceptive Pixel.
Order by: Score:
CNN
by cb_osn on Sat 10th May 2008 07:10 UTC
cb_osn
Member since:
2006-02-26

Whatever they paid, it seems that it was a great investment. Because of the "Magic Wall" and John King's expertise with it, CNN is now the only channel I watch for election coverage.

I'm sure it won't be too long before large multi-touch devices like these hit the consumer market at reasonable prices. I can't imagine what practical use we would have for them, but I know I'd love to have a few in my house.

Reply Score: 2

RE: CNN
by WereCatf on Sat 10th May 2008 07:18 UTC in reply to "CNN"
WereCatf Member since:
2006-02-15

I can't imagine what practical use we would have for them

I can't imagine anything that special that it would justify the cost of buying such a device. But something I'd personally love would be to have a big screen on the wall, all my photos, movies and music videos stored there, and to be able to sort all those with my own hands to their proper places. It's just somehow so natural to browse through pictures and arrange them on the screen using your hands. If you wanted to tag them or something, you could bring up a virtual keyboard, stretch it to a size suitable for your fingers and type away ;) You could perhaps also put on some TV channel or some video, stretch is to a smaller size and move to some corner, have it there while arranging to pictures.. That would be a very intuitive way to do those things.

EDIT: I should have watched the video first, they did all the stuff I mentioned here in that ;) So, anyway, it is cool tech and would work wonders as sort of a "living" picture and video album in your livingroom ;)

Edited 2008-05-10 07:27 UTC

Reply Score: 3

Alternative for mortals
by eduol on Sat 10th May 2008 11:56 UTC
eduol
Member since:
2007-02-07

On the cheapest side of the alimentary chain, there is an alternative that could do the magic. Wiimote whiteboard anyone?

http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~johnny/projects/wii/

Reply Score: 3

RE: Alternative for mortals
by rhyder on Sat 10th May 2008 12:57 UTC in reply to "Alternative for mortals"
rhyder Member since:
2005-09-28

That's a nice link. Interesting videos.

Reply Score: 2

That's what technicians are for
by stestagg on Sat 10th May 2008 12:01 UTC
stestagg
Member since:
2006-06-03

It would be cheaper, and look better, to have a CGI Op. sitting just out of view manipulating the display from a traditional computer. This way the presenters can focus on their performance, and not have to worry about technical issues.

Reply Score: 2

Han
by l3v1 on Sat 10th May 2008 16:27 UTC
l3v1
Member since:
2005-07-06

Many times when MS's and Apple's multitouch stuff has been brought up I tried to quote Jeff Han's work on some forums, but it just seemed nobody cared. But thing is, determination and good work gets paid in the end, this way or another.

Reply Score: 2

what i would love to see...
by hobgoblin on Sat 10th May 2008 19:24 UTC
hobgoblin
Member since:
2005-07-06

is a system of one or two screens where either of them can be tilted like a drawing board.

it should remove most worries about work strain from wrists and neck (working on a vertical or horizontal surface).

Reply Score: 2

cool to see this
by codehead78 on Sat 10th May 2008 19:46 UTC
codehead78
Member since:
2006-08-04

I saw this on CNN and wasn't sure if it was jeff han's wall. It was cool to see it used in a real application. It's a huge step forward from 'interacting' with a green screen. Also glad to see jeff doing well after all the hard work put in.

Reply Score: 1

Impressive
by dimosd on Sat 10th May 2008 19:53 UTC
dimosd
Member since:
2006-02-10

That was one impressive video (I'm not easily impressed these days).

And we are still arguing about the merits of command line vs. GUI? ;-)

Reply Score: 3

tyrione
Member since:
2005-11-21

The CNN tittilation is mental masturbation.

It's perfect for the War Room Scenario but in general use it makes Star Trek Next Generation and everything that followed seemed more interesting.

It's re-representing data in a more "hands on" way of not using a mouse, on a big wall.

Greaaaat. Now I can see this being useful for Scientists, specifically climate changes in real-time, geological activities of fault line shifts, etc., but none of that has anything to do with this Big Screen, other than it's a cute way to zoom in and out while in a standing presentation position.

What makes or breaks such displays aren't the Interfaces, but the power of the tools these interfaces are connected with and their intended purposes.

Zooming in and out of National->State->County->City view over and over with Red vs. Blue demographics, repeat and rinse 5,000 times ala CNN gets boring real fast.

Reply Score: 3