Linked by Rahul on Mon 27th Oct 2008 20:33 UTC
Linux Lifehacker reviews some of the popular Linux distributions that have provided tools to make Live USB keys, a easy task. These include Damn Small Linux, Fedora with it's cross platform liveusb-creator , Puppy Linux and Xubuntu. All systems were tested with UNetbootin except for Fedora which was run using it's own liveusb-creator. For every distribution, the minimum requirements, image size, boot time, features, things that need improvement and which users it is recommended for, is listed.
Order by: Score:

Lack of Mandriva Flash
by troy.unrau on Mon 27th Oct 2008 21:01 UTC
troy.unrau
Member since:
2007-02-23

I'm disappointed by the lack of Mandriva Flash in the comparison. This product has been commercially available for quite a while, is well tested, and 'simply works' for almost every computer system I'm tested it on. I carry it around in my coat pocket compulsively.

RE: Lack of Mandriva Flash
by Crono on Mon 27th Oct 2008 21:52 UTC in reply to "Lack of Mandriva Flash"
Crono Member since:
2006-11-08

I would have also liked to see the Debian-Live systms in there. It's not like they are new.

http://debian-live.alioth.debian.org/

Short bio thats about it
by lord-storm on Mon 27th Oct 2008 21:11 UTC
lord-storm
Member since:
2005-07-12

Not much of a real roundup but it is a good overview of some of the distro's available by the unetbootin project. USB boot is great providing support is there in the bios. Shame solaris cant boot this way as well with this project so I can run around with a key chain full of zfs drives although it has got bsd's...
http://wiki.freebsd.org/ZFS mmm I hope to see those docs...

RE: Short bio thats about it
by Dawgmatix on Tue 28th Oct 2008 15:23 UTC in reply to "Short bio thats about it"
Dawgmatix Member since:
2008-09-28

solaris can boot off a usb thumb drive. search for milax which is a tiny ~250mb opensolaris distro that can be installed to usb thumb drives.

Slax linux
by poundsmack on Mon 27th Oct 2008 21:15 UTC
poundsmack
Member since:
2005-07-13

I throw my vote in for Slax linux, great live OS. http://www.slax.org/

Xubuntu
by motang on Tue 28th Oct 2008 02:13 UTC
motang
Member since:
2008-03-27

I use Xubuntu on my EeeBox and it was installed by live USB, and it works well. ;)

Booting these in VMs?
by oobles on Tue 28th Oct 2008 02:49 UTC
oobles
Member since:
2005-11-14

Has anyone had experience with these type of VMs booting into VMs? I really like the idea of having a few appliance style VMs I could boot into VMware or other environment that I could carry around on USB keys, etc.

I'd like to extend this to light weight servers that I can move around between cloud servers. Is anyone doing this?

RE: Booting these in VMs?
by jimbofluffy on Tue 28th Oct 2008 13:26 UTC in reply to "Booting these in VMs?"
jimbofluffy Member since:
2008-07-15

Has anyone had experience with these type of VMs booting into VMs? I really like the idea of having a few appliance style VMs I could boot into VMware or other environment that I could carry around on USB keys, etc.


Not exactly pertaining to your statement, but

DSL has version they call "embedded" that comes with Q that can either be usb booted or booted in windows.

rakamaka,

I and some of my colleagues use the dsl embedded when we need to ssh from a windows cluster when there is not a program installed on the cluster to do so, though of course there are other ways to do that.

Mandriva ...
by yvesdandoy on Tue 28th Oct 2008 09:36 UTC
yvesdandoy
Member since:
2006-12-22

Funny how almost nobody ever talks about Mandriva (which in this case also has a thumb drive version !!!) thought it is one of the major Linux distro !!!

Ostracism ???

Almost ALL these require booting from USB
by rakamaka on Tue 28th Oct 2008 12:48 UTC
rakamaka
Member since:
2005-08-12

Many old computers dont have boot-from-usb options. So these distros are useless as travellers and those seeking public library, cafe, access.
Will be better if they run on top of existing MS windows.