Post a Comment
Regarding Puolsbo + Linux:
http://mjg59.livejournal.com/111853.html
(Executive summary: Poulsbo sucks, a real blunder by Intel).
The Euro price puts this device at over $800 USD without a carrier subsidy.
Even with a subsidy/markdown from a major carrier, I can't imagine any of them going more than $200.
- Good - A data capable devoce with very nice specs.
- Bad - 1GB Soldered RAM with no slot to add more.
- Good - Windows 7 (tailored) is a plus. Maybe.
How will 1GB of RAM run Windows 7, even tailored, with efficiency over time with patches & hot fixes?
It seems to me that Nokia, while well intentioned, missed the mark with this one.
Even with a subsidized price from a major carrier, anyone looking for a Netbook will quickly see that an Eee PC or Acer Aspire One will have greater expandability and a larger Hard Drive (160G instead of Nokia having a 120G) with an approx $300 USD sticker price; not over $800.
No thanks.
Heh, so one either has a 3G modem sticking out of a USB port, or a ready boost USB drive sticking out of a USB port... Either way, it's something you have to hook up. Stupid really, when all Nokia had to do was include 2 gb of ram from the beginning. As for me, if I need 3g on my netbook, I'll opt for the external 3g modem. I don't always need 3g, but I do always need 2 gb of ram.
The interesting question is why Nokia would decide to enter the Netbook business. Why ship a Windows machine when their grand new strategy is 'Maemo über alles'?
Most likely they intend to use it as a vehicle to get their Ovi stuff (and Qt) on people's desktops.
Can't wait to see how that works out.
At EUR500+ not well without major subsidies from carriers. Given carriers are already giving away cheaper netbooks with some plans (and that the more-money-than-sense crowd would want an Apple sticker on lid) I don't see the demand for this.
Some people are completely warped. Why on earth do you need more than a gigabyte of RAM in a netbook? Since when does Firefox and Flash Player demand this much RAM? It's a NETbook, not a NOTEbook.
And Firewire? Are you freaking crazy? Atom processors are too slow to do any meaningful video editing. You want Firewire, you buy a notebook with a mobile Core 2 Duo. It's a NETbook.
What's next - demanding a netbook with dual HDDs in RAID?
Typed happily on an Aspire One with 512mb of RAM and 8gb SSD.
1GB is OK if it's upgradable. Soldered down is what I call nonsense.
Heavy video editing with Atom is problematic, but to cite a pro, Firewire port is required for high-quality DV transfer from camcorders. Also, audio editing and recording are entirly possible with Atom (probably with not many real-time effects used, but that's not most important thing on the go.) And Firewire is *the* choice for reliable outboard audio.
Because Win7 runs like crap in 1gb once you open a few things, that's why. If it were a slimmed down Linux or even a slimmed down Windows it wouldn't be so bad, but try running a full Win7 in only 1 gb of ram and use it regularly for a while, then ask again why 2gb is necessary in this netbook. Ram is cheap, it consumes negligible power, and it's always better to have more especially when running the latest Windows. 2 gb is basically the sweet spot.
Heres the reasons i wont buy
1 gb of ram (soldered in?)
intel atom
windows 7
and to get it for the price it SHOULD BE anyway you need to have a contract.
Netbooks like that should cost no more than $250 with NO contract. Considering a 15.6 in notebook can be had for 400 new/shipped



