Linked by Eugenia Loli-Queru on Tue 30th Sep 2003 17:39 UTC, submitted by Yama
OSNews, Generic OSes US software giant Microsoft will tie up with a Japanese non-profit group to develop next generation operating systems for everything from refrigerators to mobile phones. The tie-up would enable appliances, cars and other gadgets worldwide that operate on the group's free TRON operating system to eventually work like personal computers.
Order by: Score:

This is crazy
by Confused on Tue 30th Sep 2003 17:44 UTC

Will this companies never learn? Microsoft cannot be trusted, first is all nice and sweet, then comes the stranglement and boom!. Another extension of M$ monoploy.

This is just dumb.
by Nicholas James on Tue 30th Sep 2003 17:49 UTC

When the age comes of putting OSs on appliances, phones I can understand, but fridges that is stupid.

Just business:
by jbett on Tue 30th Sep 2003 18:13 UTC

It's sad to see these days, but I guess it's true what they say we are all greedy bastards looking to get more of a cut than others. It's really just business IBM or Dell anyone else would want to make a similar deal just to screw em over in the end.

Ironic
by Gokul Poduval on Tue 30th Sep 2003 18:25 UTC

Take a look at this - http://slashdot.org/articles/03/07/16/1521208.shtml?tid=185&tid=190

Microsoft/U.S. goverment used trade rules (Super 301) to block it adoption by schools in Japan. And now TRON is actually co-operating with them ? Will they never learn ?

v Hi-Tech Toilette bowls
by Glanz on Tue 30th Sep 2003 18:27 UTC
Why are you so nasty with MS ?
by totothemacho on Tue 30th Sep 2003 18:32 UTC

They are continuously improving their products. They cut their prices (Win 2k3, local administration, large customers...) and are innovating in several markets (console games, PDA, Tablet PC...)

What do you expect from Microsoft ?

RE: Why are you so nasty with MS ?
by Thom on Tue 30th Sep 2003 18:40 UTC

Those people reacting this way on MS have a tunnelview; I don't think anyone in the world will be able to broaden their horizons.

Sounds like a sekt, doesn't it??

source code?
by stunji on Tue 30th Sep 2003 19:29 UTC

<< The group will make the source code for T-Kernel available in November, Mr Yamada said. >>

Does this mean that TRON is going to be open-source? This could mean good things for the Mono project if so...

Also, yeah... browsers in the fridge? I think not.

v hmmmm....
by bagdadbob on Tue 30th Sep 2003 19:39 UTC
Browser on the fridge...
by Vic Berkshire on Tue 30th Sep 2003 20:02 UTC

There MAY BE a need for Internet access in the kitchen, but it won't be on the door of my refrigerator, EVER.

The kitchen needs Internet access about as much as any other room in the house does if that's where you like to do your work and cook at the same time. Next to the stove or on the microwave, yes. But the fridge????

A networked microwave sounds pretty cool, but who needs it?

Microsoft has enough resources to develop real-time operating systems for small platform devices by itself. Isn't that what Windows CE is?

This sounds like another market-share grab by Microsoft at the expence of a smaller tech firm.

Vic

v hahahahahahhahahah
by hahahahahahhahahah on Tue 30th Sep 2003 20:07 UTC

Contacting them.

http://www.na.assoc.tron.org/

TRON Association North American Liaison Office
Accelerated Technology,
Embedded Systems Division of Mentor Graphics
720 Oak Circle Drive East
Mobile AL 36609
Phone: (251) 661-5770
Fax: (251) 661-5788
Email: na_info@assoc.tron.org
Web Site: www.na.tron.assoc.org

TRON Association
5F Katsuta Bld.
1-3-39 Mita Minato-ku
Tokyo 108-0073 JAPAN
Phone: +81-3-3454-3191
Fax: +81-3-3454-3224
Web Site: www.assoc.tron.org

RE: This is just dumb.
by slash on Tue 30th Sep 2003 20:22 UTC

"but fridges that is stupid"

Actually, people probably said the same thing about phones 10-20 years ago. I can already think about many uses for a smart Fridge. When all grossary items have Radio tags, you would be able to quickly inventory what you have in the fridge, what is expired, what is going to expire, and with an integrated lighting system, where in the fridge they are located. Heck, it can even email you stuff you might want to purchase and which grocerry stores have them on sale.

re: slash
by Rude Turnip on Tue 30th Sep 2003 20:34 UTC

"Heck, it can even email you stuff you might want to purchase and which grocerry stores have them on sale."

I don't think you're going to win any arguments by saying that receiving spam is a benefit ;)

RE: Why are you so nasty with MS ?
by Furby on Tue 30th Sep 2003 20:39 UTC

..are innovating in several markets

This word you use, "innovate" I do not think it means what you think it means.

that was unexpected
by tim on Tue 30th Sep 2003 20:58 UTC

I read a few months back that TRON was going to be retooled with a Linux kernel as a core, but retaining legacy TRON support thru emulation and such. What if this is still the case, and MS is going to use a Wine-like emulation on top of an upcoming TRON/Linux kernel? Probably not though, MS is probably doing this to kill a TRON/Linux possibility, and more likely wants to add on a Pocket PC compatibility layer.

These are exciting times for OS's.

My predicition
by Wilhelm Fitzpatrick on Tue 30th Sep 2003 21:27 UTC

Microsoft will offer a WinCE kernel with a TRON compatibility layer on top of it. There will be a big announcement, with lots of smiling guys in suits talking about how their company is committed to use it in their embedded projects. Five years later, their companies are shipping products using an evolutionary descendant of "original" TRON.

If you are reading this in 2008, please let me know how I did ;)

v This is great!
by FireMouth on Tue 30th Sep 2003 21:32 UTC
v RE: hmmmm....
by Bill Lamar on Tue 30th Sep 2003 21:45 UTC
RE: Why are you so nasty with MS ?
by The Pessimist on Tue 30th Sep 2003 22:33 UTC

"..are innovating in several markets
This word you use, "innovate" I do not think it means what you think it means.
"

I think he knows better than some people who think that Linux is innovative, that is an OS that plagiarize his *nix ancestor for the internal, and plagiarize Windows on the surface.

Linux did not bring any innovation. Windows bring a few.

RE: This is great!
by Kar 120c on Tue 30th Sep 2003 22:47 UTC

Your point might have come out clearer if you compared company to company, or product to product, rather than company to product.

So, MS will tie us up?
by Anonymous on Tue 30th Sep 2003 22:56 UTC

The tie-up would enable appliances, cars and other gadgets worldwide that operate on the group's free TRON operating system to eventually work like personal computers.
<P>
I guess they'll have to tie us up. I certainly don't want my appliances, vehicles, usw to work like a pc with MS's malware.

RE: Why are you so nasty with MS ?
by Kar 120c on Tue 30th Sep 2003 22:58 UTC

"I think he knows better than some people who think that Linux is innovative,"

I think it's sad that instead of countering any points of what is or is not innovative with either operating system, you just resort to yelling "because!". If you have any particular instances of Microsoft innovating, actually stating them will make a case for your argument. Starting out from a faulty premise as basis for your attack on another operating system not being innovative makes you seem like you have no idea what you're talking about with either. As with your point of "One program which runs on an OS is not innovative, therefore nothing in the operating system itself, and all other programs for it are also not innovative".

TRON truth.
by BR on Tue 30th Sep 2003 22:58 UTC

He he. Well at least the entire plan comes with an MCP.

v I got moderated down for this?
by Glanz on Wed 1st Oct 2003 00:02 UTC
About innovation from MS
by 3seas on Wed 1st Oct 2003 01:17 UTC

Hey Martha, the fridge has a virus again.....

Tron is BSD-like I believe...
by mabhatter on Wed 1st Oct 2003 01:33 UTC

I believe that Tron is BSD-like...I looked it up when /. posted it a while back. So there are free versions [the original in the 80's] but most versions in actual use are not-free. I have a feeling this will be a repeat of Kerberos! That was BSD, and MS used the usual "Embrace, Extend, Extinguish" [Reg TM MS corp. patent pending] to twist it just enough that you still have to choose MS for best results, or have to get in and tweak the MS to be "compatible".

They looked like such nice little guys too....oh well...make a deal with the devil and that's what happens. It's not like everyone doesn't know by now...gotta learn the hard way!

Gnnnnh...
by Vecc on Wed 1st Oct 2003 02:01 UTC

Ohhh, good. ctrl+alt+delete just to open my fridge :/

And YES, I understand that it can be usefull to have my fridge on the Net, Maybe just to notify me if a fuse or something else is broken. But I CAN'T beleive my eyes when I see ppl REALLY belive in MS doing this.

Furthermore. I have seen a bluescreen on my local...hmm what is it called internationally.... ATM Box? Where you are getting money from your own account by the help of a credit card. I mean, BLUESCREEN. Ohh, how nice to have my money in that place......

control-alt-delete to flush my toilet
by Jed on Wed 1st Oct 2003 05:50 UTC

I like the idea of embedded toilet browsers. Too bad microsoft "dumped" that venture.

tron
by x marks the spot on Wed 1st Oct 2003 07:57 UTC

so trno will be swept under the carpet to be replaced with a windows ce version. joy. ;) i think i will avoid any microwaevs with 'windows inside' stickers on it.

What is TRON?
by John Blink on Wed 1st Oct 2003 08:36 UTC

Is it an OS?
A kernel?
What benefit does this give MS?
What benefit does this give the creators of TRON?

I don't understand anything from that article.

This Brings...
by Zaphrod on Wed 1st Oct 2003 08:47 UTC

new meaning to the phrase "Windows Froze on me"

RE: RE: This is just dumb.
by Wrawrat on Wed 1st Oct 2003 09:15 UTC

When all grossary items have Radio tags, you would be able to quickly inventory what you have in the fridge, what is expired, what is going to expire, and with an integrated lighting system, where in the fridge they are located. Heck, it can even email you stuff you might want to purchase and which grocerry stores have them on sale.

People are already getting more and more lazy everyday... and you want to make their life even easier?

That is a completely retarded idea to me. It would probably turn people in drolling zombie slaves. Then again, I guess I'm just too conservative for computerising my whole life (even if I'm only 20).

Re: What is TRON?
by elmimmo on Wed 1st Oct 2003 11:45 UTC

AFAIK, it is just a whitepaper describing the outlines and structure of a conceptual OS. There are several implementations of it, depending of the intended use, from things like DVDs to full desktop OSs.

Bad Move
by azazel on Wed 1st Oct 2003 11:47 UTC

As others have touched on, Microsoft really doesn't know how to behave in a cooperative situation. I believe they will get frustrated by attempting to cooperate with the TRON people and will eventually take all their ideas and aggressively market some wonderful "TRON-compatible" embedded OS (maybe a TRON based WinCE)... the original developers of TRON will be shut out, and the product will come under the Microsoft umbrella.

History has shown us this type of behaviour over and over again.

Microsoft is the only group interested in seeing this.
by aldousd666 on Wed 1st Oct 2003 12:42 UTC

TRON's strength lies in it's standalone stablility. I hardly think that anyone would want a TRON comapatibility layer on CE other than Microsoft themselves. TRON is more widely used than MS-Windows, so they see an untapped market to abuse. This won't in any way help their case with the US DOJ. Let 'em drown in it

comments
by sam on Wed 1st Oct 2003 13:56 UTC

TRON stands for "The Realtime Operating System Nucleus" and uITRON stands for micro-industrial. Both are specs similar to POSIX, POSIX 1003.1b (realtime) and POSIX 1003.1c (threads).

All the embedded OS in Japan is written according to uITRON specs. All the embedded OS in the US (QNX, LynxOS and VxWorks) are written according to POSIX specs.

POSIX is an IEEE spec. TRON is not.

comments
by sam on Wed 1st Oct 2003 13:59 UTC

The (formerly) RedHat eCos embedded OS has good uITRON compatibility, but have very limited POSIX compatibility --- which makes it useless in North America.

Linux did not bring any innovation
by Pat on Wed 1st Oct 2003 14:29 UTC

"that is an OS that plagiarize his *nix ancestor for the internal, and plagiarize Windows on the surface."

Let's see. The first versions of windows were based on DOS witch was copied from Unix with an interface copied from MacOS. Then there's Exchange from IMAP, then the IE browser from Netscape the Active directory from LDAP all the while copying softwares from all over the place and integrating them for free in their OS in order to kill the original developpers as a corporate strategie to keep the market cornered while pretending that it was just an attempt to make their software "better"...

"You really want to call THAT innovation?!!

RE: Why are you so nasty with MS ?
by Great Cthulhu on Wed 1st Oct 2003 14:33 UTC

Thom, you do not see any problems with having a single company holding a monopoly over the OS and Office suites markets, and using that monopoly to gain unfair advantages over competitors?

As our society becomes more and more integrated with technology, no company should have that kind of power.

What is an OS?
by Anonymous on Wed 1st Oct 2003 19:32 UTC

sam wrote:
> All the embedded OS in Japan is written according to uITRON specs. All the embedded OS in the US (QNX, LynxOS and VxWorks) are written according to POSIX specs.

Can someone please point me to an introduction for profanes about what is POSIX, how it influences OS designs or how OSs relate to/depend on it and, ultimately, how other standards differ from POSIX?

comments
by sam on Wed 1st Oct 2003 20:12 UTC

POSIX doesn't influence OS design at all. It only defined in terms of API interfaces, not actually how those interfaces are implemented.

A POSIX compliant OS can be a monolithic kernel (various UNIX) or it can be a microkernel (QNX).

Sake or crack ?
by Billy on Wed 1st Oct 2003 22:59 UTC

Well, this isn't April 1. So, either Sakamura had one round too many of sake with his friends or some yakuzas sold him too much crack.
Do these guys want to turn most appliances into Windows malware carriers ?

Ah ah ah, internet on the fridge
by rnrboy on Thu 2nd Oct 2003 08:08 UTC

Why not internet on the door of my toilet ... oh wait!