posted by Detlef Niehof on Fri 4th Dec 2009 22:54
Conversations With Google getting involved with more and more internet fields, I am looking for a really good alternative to Google search in order to get away from them... ;-)
Some time ago I made some sketchy comparisons between several more or less randomly chosen search engines and Google, but was not satisfied with the search results.
So, what is currently a Google alternative that you can really recommend?
Previous ConversationNext Conversation
Comments:
Comment by Alex Forster
by Alex Forster on Sat 5th Dec 2009 20:05 UTC
Alex Forster
Member since:
2005-08-12
RE:
by Alex Forster on Sat 5th Dec 2009 20:07 in reply to "Comment by Alex Forster"
Alex Forster Member since:
2005-08-12

Damnit OSNews.

Reply Score: 2

Comment by Laurence
by Laurence on Sun 6th Dec 2009 13:12 UTC
Laurence
Member since:
2007-03-26

* Yahoo
* Bing
* Altavista (I still prefer babelfish over Google Translate)
* Ask
* Lycos

that's all that spring to mind at the moment.
I used to use altavista 24/7 but these days it's just Google

Reply Score: 2

RE:
by Detlef Niehof on Sun 6th Dec 2009 22:19 in reply to "Comment by Laurence"
Detlef Niehof Member since:
2006-05-02

Thanks!

Are these just some random search engines that you know exist, or do you list them because you think (or you are even sure) they are as good as Google?

Reply Score: 1

RE:
by Laurence on Mon 7th Dec 2009 00:23 in reply to "RE: "
Laurence Member since:
2007-03-26

It's been a many years since I've used most of these but:

* I used to swear by altavista before Google.
It's a very powerful search engine (or used to be 12 years ago)

* Never really rated Lycos other than a back up engine (back then you couldn't guarantee search engines had indexed the pages you wanted)

* When it was released, Ask was supposed to have a new and interesting approach to searching - I'm not sure how powerful or reliable it is in practice though as I've gotten lazy with relying on Google.

So in short - I can only really vouch for altavista - and even that recommendation is based on very dated experience.


Do keep us updated with your thoughts / experiences though - I'd love to find some alternatives too.

Reply Score: 2

Bing
by David on Mon 7th Dec 2009 18:51 UTC
David
Member since:
1997-10-01

I'm afraid that Bing is the only one that's likely to give Google a run for its money, quality-wise. So if you'd like to stop supporting big bad Google by giving your eyeballs to Microsoft, well good luck with that!

I'm not sure why people are getting so agitated about Google's expansion into new services. If you don't want to use them, then don't. They're not forcing you to use the Google DNS service (and by the way, there's OpenDNS for that anyway). You don't have to use Gmail, Chrome, ChromeOS, Google Apps. You do have to use YouTube, unless you just want to miss out on a lot of stuff, but Google doesn't force you to use their browser to watch YouTube videos or do searches, so I'm not sure what the problem is. Are you afraid that once they do get a bigger footprint then they'll pull a Microsoft and try to leverage their monopoly?

Reply Score: 1

RE:
by Laurence on Tue 8th Dec 2009 14:22 in reply to "Bing"
Laurence Member since:
2007-03-26

I'm afraid that Bing is the only one that's likely to give Google a run for its money, quality-wise. So if you'd like to stop supporting big bad Google by giving your eyeballs to Microsoft, well good luck with that!


I couldn't disagree with that statement more.

In terms of indexing sites, theres plenty of search engines that are comparable to Google.

Data in the internet is effectively free to collate and organise. Therefore you don't have to be a large organisation to write an advanced search engine (remember, Google was only a research project when Yahoo was already worth $millions)

Furthermore, MSs search engines of old have frequently proved inadequate compared to many smaller brands - hence why I've never even bothered with Bing now.

Reply Score: 2

RE: Alternatives to Google search ;-)
by Meanwhile on Tue 8th Dec 2009 14:47 UTC
Meanwhile
Member since:
2005-09-03

You could have a look at Exalead http://light.labs.exalead.com/ , more info:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exalead

Reply Score: 1

Duck Duck Go
by d4rkn1ght on Wed 9th Dec 2009 05:08 UTC
d4rkn1ght
Member since:
2006-01-02

I have been playing with Duck Duck Go http://duckduckgo.com/ lately! ;)

Reply Score: 1

alltheweb
by bogomipz on Mon 14th Dec 2009 15:08 UTC
bogomipz
Member since:
2005-07-11

Before Google, and after altavista, I used alltheweb.

It was created by FAST Search & Transfer, which has since been acquired by Microsoft. Alltheweb.com seems to be in the hands of Yahoo! now.

Reply Score: 2

About the alternatives
by irbis on Thu 17th Dec 2009 21:45 UTC
irbis
Member since:
2005-07-08

Infopeople's Best Search Tools Chart is a good starting point: http://infopeople.org/search/chart.html

The biggest web search providers seem to only have strengthened their leading positions during the past years: http://searchenginewatch.com/3634991 so there may be few alternatives in the same category of general web search engines with huge databases. But the bigger is not always better. Often you might be able to find better information by using some specialized search engine http://www.dmoz.org/Computers/Internet/Searching/Search_Engines/Spe... or a regional search engine: http://www.searchenginesindex.com/

There are also interesting true alternatives that do the whole concept of searching the web in a different way, like:
http://www.hakia.com/ (semantic search)
http://www.wolframalpha.com/ ("computational knowledge engine")

You might also like to try Scroogle that offers a more secure way of using Google (not sure what Google thinks about Scroogle though): https://ssl.scroogle.org/

Reply Score: 2

Thanks!
by Detlef Niehof on Fri 18th Dec 2009 09:55 UTC
Detlef Niehof
Member since:
2006-05-02

Thank you for all your suggestions. I'll gladly try them out in the next weeks and months!

Reply Score: 1

private search
by eksasol on Wed 6th Jan 2010 07:14 UTC
eksasol
Member since:
2009-04-05

You need to look for search engine that doesn't record your IP address. I use "Scroogle" (https://ssl.scroogle.org).

And also "ixquick.com". If you click on "my settings", you can turn on SSL and anonymous picture search.

Both of these have Firefox addon for them.

But Scroogle only prevent Google from recording your IP, your search can still be monitored if someone have access to your connection or if you are using internet of the corporation you're working in (most definitely). Or if you simply go to any website at all, the website can record your IP. Then in that case, you could use Tor or some VPN.

Reply Score: 1