Linked by Thom Holwerda on Fri 19th May 2006 20:14 UTC
Microsoft A senior Microsoft executive told a BBC documentary that people should use commercial software if they're looking for stability. "Some people want to use community-based software, and they get value out of sharing with other people in the community. Other people want the reliability and the dependability that comes from a commercial software model. And again, at the end of the day, you make the choice based on what has the highest value to you."
Permalink for comment 126352
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Murray's statement can horribly backfire
by ingraham on Sat 20th May 2006 01:36 UTC
ingraham
Member since:
2006-05-20

Ignoring for a moment whether or not non-commercial open source software is reliable or dependable, Murray opens a can of worms by suggesting that commercial proprietary software is. Some quick examples of how relying on Microsoft's dependability would land you in a heap of trouble, in roughly chronological order:

OS/2: Abandoned by MS
Windows 3.0: Delayed
Windows 95: Delayed by 2 years
Windows NT: Delayed 1 year
Windows XP: Delayed over a year. Windows ME was rushed out to fill what would have been a 5 year gap between releases.
Windows Vista: Delayed at least 4 years

Internet Explorer: No major updates for at least 4 years.
IE for Mac: Abandoned
IE for Unix: Abandoned

Visual Studio .Net: Numerous delays of various releases, plus essentially abandons legacy VB6 code.

Microsoft Bob: A terrible idea to begin with, it's good that MS killed it. But if you were an IT guy who rolled it out or a developer that put effort into working with it you got burned.

Passport: Failed to gain market acceptance, eventually killed.

WinFS: Removed from already-delayed Vista launch; no way to know when or if it will be released.


As a gamer, I think Windows XP is the best gaming OS ever. But if I worked at Microsoft, I would try really hard NOT to bring up "reliability and dependability." Now Murray, Ballmer, and Gates are going to spend the next week defending the comment.

Reply Score: 4