Linked by Adam S on Thu 18th Aug 2005 23:28 UTC
OSNews, Generic OSes I have just posted a new OSNews feature, email notification on comment reply. It's not the only change we made around here today. Read on for further details.
Permalink for comment 20469
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[2]: threaded v. not threaded
by Moochman on Sat 20th Aug 2005 02:37 UTC in reply to "RE: threaded v. not threaded"
Member since:

You can't have a reply mechanism in place, complete with a link to the page of replies, without the threading mechanism being inherent. The threading is already in OSNews v3, and people are already making use of it. Now that @so-and-so etc. is out of fashion, it's become near-impossible to sort through what's being responded to without having some sort of threading view. While you personally may not use it, a lot of people would be a lot happier if they could follow conversations with some bit of coherency.

I don't see why this is so important, after all comments should be about adding useful information to a news item and not so much about discussing totally unrelated topics. ;)

Why would they be unrelated? That seems like a much more Slashdot-esque behavior to me than what I've come to expect from OSNews readers.

Besides, threading allows you to simply skip over unrelated conversations...

One thing I might advocate is a limit to thread depth; e.g. three replies deep is the max. This would ensure that threads never got too convoluted and out of hand in terms of followability.

Reply Parent Score: 1