Linked by Thom Holwerda on Sat 17th Feb 2007 18:45 UTC, submitted by GhePeU
X11, Window Managers David Reveman writes: "I'd like to get all of you updated on the compiz related things discussed at the X developer conference that was held last week. My talk was mainly focused on 'what's next' and how to get desktop compositing in X to the next level." He also discussed the fork: "I had the chance to talk to Quinn Storm from the beryl project during xdevconf. I would have hoped that the current situation with beryl could be improved but it seems like Quinn at least isn't interested in that. However, after talking to Quinn it's very clear to me that the fork was partially motivated by assumptions that were wrong."
Permalink for comment 213936
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[3]: sour grapes?
by cmost on Sat 17th Feb 2007 22:08 UTC in reply to "RE[2]: sour grapes?"
cmost
Member since:
2006-07-16

Whether or not Beryl is using hacks to accomplish some of its effects is irrelevant. What's obviously at issue is the Compiz folks are pissed off about the fork. Now, the fork has moved ahead and fanned out in directions Compiz hasn't yet gone, the compiz devs are making sure they point out every flaw in Beryl while at the same time using stability and "doing it right" as their own excuse for being slow. So what?!? Beryl devs made it clear what they forked that Beryl's purpose for being was to act as a test bed for new plugins and technologies not yet stable enough to make it into Compiz. Obviously this is going to require some workarounds or hacks while stable underlying infrastructure gets put into place in the X server or elsewhere. As long as Beryl ends up with code that works while they clean it up for future releases, who cares if some elements are hackish for the time being. The end user isn't going to see that end of it nor is he likely to care. As for Beryl devs stealing the "fixes" or whatever from Compiz, that's the sort of sour grapes attitude I was referring to. If Compiz doesn't want other developers using their code then don't make it open source. Finally, it's clear that there are Compiz people and Beryl people and that a debate will rage ad nauseum over which is better. Use what you like. I will.

Edited 2007-02-17 22:10

Reply Parent Score: 5