Linked by Eugenia Loli on Sat 24th Mar 2007 18:55 UTC, submitted by irbis
X11, Window Managers "The Compiz and Beryl teams are discussing a merger. Posts on the Compiz forum and Beryl mailing list indicate that the projects are discussing how to execute a merger and work together to deliver a single compositing window manager to give 'bling' to the Linux desktop."
Permalink for comment 224359
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE: Wish this happened more often..
by MacTO on Sat 24th Mar 2007 22:12 UTC in reply to "Wish this happened more often.."
MacTO
Member since:
2006-09-21

> there is a TREMEMDOUS amount of duplication of effort in linux.

While some of this duplicated effort is counter productive, I highly doubt that most of it is. For example, people often complain about the duplicated effort between Gnome and KDE. The thing is, these are rather different environments. If I were stuck with KDE, I would probably use Mac OS X full time because I hate the complexity of KDE. If it went the other way, there would be people using Windows because they would simply find Gnome too limiting.

For more abstract projects, projects that probably end up looking quite similar to the end user (like Compiz and Beryl), you still have to deal with the needs of the developers. Just because one group thinks one API is great, doesn't mean that another group will think the API is great. Or what about the teams themselves? Just because you have 1 team + 1 team doesn't mean that you get the output of 2 teams when you combine them. If people cannot agree on goals, or they cannot stand working with each other for social reasons, then you aren't going to see a combined output. You may see a slightly higher output. You may see a diminished output. But it probably won't be additive.

Reply Parent Score: 5