Linked by Thom Holwerda on Wed 4th Jul 2007 23:08 UTC
The ReactOS project has released a new newsletter. "The past few weeks have seen quite a lot of activity. At least six major blocker bugs were dealt with, ranging from the network issue to various bugs in the command line console." On top of that: "Some people aren't aware that ReactOS was one of several projects that received hardware to test on from One Laptop Per Child. Aleksey has been playing around with it, slowly coaxing ReactOS to boot."
Permalink for comment 253232
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Member since:
2007-03-29
"Do you feel you know something that noone else does?
If so, please quote. If not, please don't disturb the people putting real efforts in the project or just being interested."
(Assuming you are responding to "legally dead," a bit hard to determine around here).
Given the past problems with "audits", "NT source code leaks", plus all the FUD being spread by people claiming to be ReactOS *supporters*, plus the fact that Microsoft has raised the spectre of IP violations against Linux, it's not at all surprising that people expect ReactOS to run into legal issues when v1.0 finally arrives.
While I don't question any copyright violations (though the whole "audit" issue has even gotten me a bit concerned about that), there is still the question of patents. IANAL, etc., etc., but I'd find it truly amazing to think that someone could create a close of the Windows OS without violating at least *some* of Microsoft's IP (in the form of patents).
I'd love to see the project succeed, etc., etc., but like almost any reasonable person who is not rabidly anti-Microsoft, I suspect it will be extremely difficult to create a Windows clone that does not violate any patents Microsoft holds.
I could not possibly imagine any company like Dell pre-installing ReactOS on their systems. I cannot imagine any big firms standardizing on ReactOS. The risk is just too great.
ReactOS will probably do okay as long as it flies under the radar and gets adopted by anti-Microsoft types who absolutely must run Windows (though that seems like an oxymoronic attitude to me), but even if it *does* get finished, I can't imagine it would ever enjoy the popularity of, say, Linux.
In retrospect, it's a good thing that software patents are a relatively recent thing. Imagine what the world would be like right now if AT&T had been able to patent everything associated with UNIX (okay,so the patents would have expired by now, but still...).