Linked by Smith Johnson on Wed 16th Jan 2008 01:24 UTC, submitted by Dan Warne
Apple Like an anorexic fashion model, Apple's new super-thin MacBook Air has made too many compromises for the sake of being skinny. With such emaciated specs, many are asking: who would buy it?
Permalink for comment 296285
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
your "pro" is not my "pro"
by jziegler on Wed 16th Jan 2008 09:08 UTC
Member since:

It seems, that people forget that not everyone has the same needs.

Since I already have a MBP, 6 months old, I'm not considering MBA right now. I definitely will, in the future (year, year and a half). Hopefully, SSD will become cheaper by then.

As a sysadmin with some management roles:
* glossy screen - no my favourite, but not really a problem
* no dvd drive - only really needed it for installing, can be solved by I cheap external one, wihich I already do have

* no fw - don't need it
* no HSDPA/3G - why would I want it? my phone has it and it speaks Bluetooth. So does MBA. Problem solved.

* one USB port - never actually needed more than one. What I use it for on the go is : usb keys, usb-to-serial. With the external dvd, I would need the USB for this as well, but that would sit on my desk. It can sit there with a USB hub as well

* non-replaceable battery - yes, sucks a bit. However by the time it's dead, it would be time for a new notebook anyway. I guess it was a compromise to keep the size small. Also less latches, screws and connectors - less things to break/fall off.

* no microphone input - no need for that

So in my opinion, it's a very good product.

Reply Score: 3