Linked by vermaden on Wed 21st May 2008 19:28 UTC
Graphics, User Interfaces How would I describe today's GUIs? A mess. -- A mess that grew as new features were needed, with lack of proper design, with a desire to keep backward compatibility, and with tools from the past trying to achieve future needs. I propose a new design philosophy for GUIs. We'll call it Vermaden's GUI. Note: This is the latest entry in our 2008 article contest.
Permalink for comment 315167
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Two flaws
by Ford Prefect on Wed 21st May 2008 23:43 UTC
Ford Prefect
Member since:

I like your article very much.

Flaw No 1: A Gui needs some air to breath. Your proposals are fixing the problems you mention but also create new ones. Please consider the question "where can I give some space to guide the user?" .. you removed clutter, but the slimmed down versions look confusing for most users, too. Esp. your Sonata example.

Flaw No 2: It's true that vector graphics are lots better than their pixmap counterparts in regards of appearance (if done right). Still, if you do a comparison between two scalings, you have to do it fairly. You didn't use one of the well established scaling algorithms which provide a much better quality than your simplest-possible-method.

Edited 2008-05-21 23:44 UTC

Reply Score: 5