Linked by Eugenia Loli-Queru on Tue 24th Jun 2008 00:34 UTC
Mac OS X Although Apple is marketing Mac OS X Snow Leopard as an operating system update with "no new features," under the hood improvements will actually translate into a slew of new enhancements, five of which are described herein.
Permalink for comment 319651
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Bloat?
by saucerful on Tue 24th Jun 2008 04:58 UTC
saucerful
Member since:
2008-06-12

Can someone running OS X confirm the sizes of some of those apps... How the heck is this TextEdit application 22mb? AbiWord compiled for Linux x86 is 5mb and I have to assume something called "TextEdit" has less features (again, I don't use OS X so maybe that assumption is my problem).

Then again, look at these other apps:

iChat 111mb / Pidgin 2mb
Mail 287mb / Thunderbird 33mb
Safari 64mb / Firefox 4mb

(Note that even the upcoming versions of all the Mac apps are still substantially larger)

Of course, as I am sure someone will point out, the size of the install might have little to do with performance (both theoretically and empirically). It could be a difference between binaries on OS X and Linux? Or perhaps Mac apps have tons of documentation? Or perhaps the old apps contain both PowerPC and x86 binaries?

Or perhaps Linux apps make use of a lot more shared libraries hence the applications themselves need to implement less functionality. On the other hand, I would think that a private company (Apple) could facilitate sharing of code more effectively than an amorphous group of worldwide developers (OSS)...

Edited 2008-06-24 05:02 UTC