Linked by Thom Holwerda on Sat 23rd Aug 2008 15:37 UTC
Editorial Earlier this week, we ran a story on GoboLinux, and the distribution's effort to replace the Filesystem Hierarchy Standard with a more pleasant, human-readable, and logical design. A lot of people liked the idea of modernising/replacing the FHS, but just as many people were against doing so. Valid arguments were presented both ways, but in this article, I would like to focus on a common sentiment that came forward in that discussion: normal users shouldn't see the FHS, and advanced users are smart enough to figure out how the FHS works.
Permalink for comment 327748
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE: what is wrong with FHS?
by Don Grayson on Sat 23rd Aug 2008 18:01 UTC in reply to "what is wrong with FHS?"
Don Grayson
Member since:

Other than the odd folder names, i really dont see anything wrong with FHS. Maybe making the names slightly more human readable, like kristoph suggested would be good, but i _really_ like having all executable files in a single folder, and all libraries in a single folder.

The problem with this, as Gobo pointed out, is that in the FHS all your executables are NOT in the same folder. There's /bin, /sbin, /usr/bin, /usr/sbin, /usr/local/bin, /usr/local/sbin, /opt, etc. It doesn't get any better for the libraries, documentation or anything else really and the only standardization across the various Distributions is that they can use those folders, not what must go where.

Gobo's effort does seem to accomplish a great deal for both developer and user. Developers can still use /etc, /bin, /lib but the end user never sees them! Their ability to install and run different versions of the same libraries would be a great help in a lot of situations. For instance, I installed OpenSuSE's official releases for TCL 8.5.2 and VTCL 1.6.0. VTCL won't run on TCL 8.5.2 and hasn't been updated yet, how does your average computer user figure that one out?

These sorts of problems are not isolated in Linux, and forward looking ideas like Gobo might work or might not, but at least it puts a spotlight on the problem and gets people thinking about it.

Reply Parent Score: 7