Linked by Thom Holwerda on Fri 16th Sep 2005 21:02 UTC, submitted by Josh
Linux Klik is a system which creates self-contained packages of programmes installable over the web with a single click. In this article Kurt Pfeifle discusses the potential uses of this technology for helping the non-coding contributors to KDE. He also looks at how the system works and the obvious security issues involved.
Permalink for comment 32914
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
MysterMask
Member since:
2005-07-12

On Linux distros a set of basic _packages_ make the OS.

The discussion is not about OS installation but application management. And it's not forbidden for Linux to install additional libraries as part of the OS core, if the library is widely used.
BTW: An OSX system installation consists of a set of packages, too (e. g. the base system, the BSD subsystem, the X11 package, etc.).


Hence I deduce it would be technically possible to create 3rd party package repositories for Windows as well. No freedom lost.

Yes. But that contradicts the repository paradigm. How does your software management system knows where to get software if not from a central repository? You have to configure your management app to get software from elsewhere. And that means "discover" it first - and voilą: your back at the good old discovery paradigm.

The MS example was only to illustrate that people probably would not accept such a thing from a commercial OS vendor, so I fail to see why this would be a positive goal for free software. Centralization might make software management easier but that has a price: Not only does it create dependency, it creates also centralized points of failures and insecurity (e. g. if your repository get's hacked).

Reply Parent Score: 1