Linked by Thom Holwerda on Wed 24th Sep 2008 07:50 UTC
Apple The situation regarding Apple's App Store for the iPhone is getting weirder by the day. Several applications have been rejected from the App Store based on seemingly dubious claims such as duplication of functionality (even though they didn't duplicate anything), or alikeness to default applications. Two such cases made headline news over the past few days; Podcaster and MailWrangler. The developers of these applications openly protested against these rejections, and apparently, Apple doesn't really like that. Apple now reiterates that rejections fall under the NDA, prohibiting developers from speaking up about rejections.
Permalink for comment 331242
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Naughty Apple
by REM2000 on Wed 24th Sep 2008 09:15 UTC
REM2000
Member since:
2006-07-25

I think apple is being a little over protective over the apps being allowed on the app store.

The idea is a solid one, ensure that only good apps are allowed onto the store.

However apps which crash have been allowed onto the store, apps which are in competition with the supplied iPhone apps are being rejected for no reason (podcast app).

NDA's on rejections is getting a little harsh now, and as many have said this is not going to give apple a very good image.

However it's worth bearing in mind that the app store is in it's infantsy, so hopefully apple will grow and learn from it's mistakes, as will competitors.

However the iPhone is still a very innovative product and has brought a breath of fresh air to the whole mobile phone platform. We now have Android so things are looking really good to the consumer and business consumer.

I still love my iPhone it is the first phone which does everything i need incredibly well, surfing the net, receiving emails, sms, pictures and a variety of other things are done so well with the iPhone.

On a side note it is slightly annoying that anyone wishing to defend or produce an argument for apple is instantly labeled a fanboi. Where comments even pre-empt this by suggesting that if anyone has anything good to say about apple then instantly you must be a blind fanboi. There is a reason why a lot of people use Apple products, as there is windows and linux products, it comes down to that they work the best for us. As ive said i use an iPhone and obsolutley love it, my mum has an iphone and loves it also, in fact everyone i know (real life, not on the internet) loves their iphone. I use Mac OSX because it works well with me at home, i use Windows at work as it works best.

Im all up for constructive discussion's but without the name calling and with the chance for some people to provide a for argument, not just an against.

Reply Score: 4