Linked by Thom Holwerda on Wed 24th Sep 2008 07:50 UTC
Apple The situation regarding Apple's App Store for the iPhone is getting weirder by the day. Several applications have been rejected from the App Store based on seemingly dubious claims such as duplication of functionality (even though they didn't duplicate anything), or alikeness to default applications. Two such cases made headline news over the past few days; Podcaster and MailWrangler. The developers of these applications openly protested against these rejections, and apparently, Apple doesn't really like that. Apple now reiterates that rejections fall under the NDA, prohibiting developers from speaking up about rejections.
Permalink for comment 331308
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
This is utter BS....
by kryogenix on Wed 24th Sep 2008 19:34 UTC
kryogenix
Member since:
2008-01-06

The people defending Apple's actions here need to have their head examined.

If MS disallowed a competing product to Pocket Word on Windows CE/Windows Mobile/Whatever people would be calling for their heads on pitchforks even though they CLEARLY have no monopoly in the mobile space. ZOMGWTFBBQ ANTITRUST ANTITRUST ANTITRUST ARRRRRGGGHHHHH!!!!!!!

*BTW WinCE really does suck monkey nuts and is quite a joke, I've owned several CE PDA's and they all ended up running NetBSD/hpcmips or embedded Linux eventually*

I'll be damned if I wasted hours of my life banging my head against the wall to learn YET ANOTHER development environment to be treated like writing software for their platform is a privilege and I better toe the party line or ELSE. THEN I spend months writing my cool little app only to have them say it might remotely compete with an Apple app on the phone and it will never see the light of day.

I find this behavior disgusting and really shows how much Apple cares about the people who keep them in business. If it weren't for the handful of people willing to develop software for Apple products, Apple would be irrelevant. It also shows how much love they have for consumers who may like the other app better than the Apple offering.

In most people's eyes, bundled software=crapware. Who cares if an app duplicates the functionality of a built-in app? What if it does the job....*gasp*....BETTER?! Oh wait, the fanboys will come in saying no one could POSSIBLY be more talented than divinely-inspired Apple developers even though most of the initial heavy lifting developing OS X was done in the 80's by talented NeXT developers when Apple struggled and failed to bring a modern competitive OS to market during the 90's.

I love MacOS X and I loved NeXTstep. I will continue to use MacOS X (both on my PPC macs and generic PC's) and will happily develop software for it as it is fairly open to a degree. But this BS with the iPhone is appalling.

I will wholeheartedly recommend to all of my students I teach in my IT courses and anyone I know to buy an HTC phone based on Android and just ignore the iPhone altogether if they value their rights and freedom.

I think they have some neat toys but as a company, Apple is twice as evil as Microsoft and they really don't care about the people who help make them great. Including their customers.

Jobs can suck it.

Reply Score: 4