Linked by Thom Holwerda on Sun 24th May 2009 12:06 UTC
Legal Mid-April, the four founders of The Pirate Bay were found guilty of being accessories to breaching copyright law; they aided in breaching copyright of 33 files. As a result, they were sentenced to one year in jail and a 2.75 million EUR fine. However, it was quickly revealed that the judge in the case was heavily biased, and ever since then there's been a search for a judge who is actually not involved with any pro-copyright groups or with the lawyers working for the entertainment industry in this case. Turns out that's actually kind of hard.
Permalink for comment 365235
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[3]: Simply amazing
by Doc Pain on Sun 24th May 2009 19:52 UTC in reply to "RE[2]: Simply amazing"
Doc Pain
Member since:
2006-10-08

Of course it should be fair to say that judges and other officers of the court (I.e. lawyers) should be banned from joining any professional bodies or political parties.


As soon as it causes conflicts with their work as judges - YES, but in general, NO.

If I would apply such a requirement to Germany, there would be almost no politicians left: Most of the members of our parliament and many ministers are lawyers (and most of these even work as lawyers in parallel to their work as politicians). But hey, maybe it would be better for our country if "ordinary" people would rule it, instead of ... greedy persons with no relationship towards honesty and counscious (and even the law).

To get back on topic: A judge with no involvement into copyright topics could be a good solution, because there can't be conflicts from his ruling to, maybe, his "job next to this one". He would be able to make statements out of an educated standpoint and a healthy thinking, instead of fearing how his ruling could have a negative effect on his fellow's business or organisation.

A judge with experience in copyright topics could do so, too, as long, as I said, there's no interference with other interests he may stand for.

Reply Parent Score: 2