Linked by Jordan Spencer Cunningham on Wed 9th Sep 2009 21:36 UTC, submitted by Moulinneuf
Apple After back and forth rumors about the health of Apple's revered Steve Jobs way back in last year and the beginning of 2009, it turned out that he really did have some health problems: complications with his liver requiring a transplant. It was supposed that he'd return to Apple by the end of June, and now he's finally made his first public appearance since he first took his medical leave of absence earlier this year.
Permalink for comment 383573
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[12]: Comment by haus
by abraxas on Fri 11th Sep 2009 22:39 UTC in reply to "RE[11]: Comment by haus"
abraxas
Member since:
2005-07-07

Well, I had cancer a few years back, and it didn't kill me. I will not presume to know your background as well as you seem to know mine, but I think I am more qualified then most to give an opinion on the subject.


I never claimed to know your background. I don't know where you got that idea from. You are definitely NOT more qualified to give an opinion because you have no specific knowledge of this case.

I am not the guy who desperately needed a liver in Tenessee, and ended up getting bumped down the list because some guy in california was a bit worse off then him.


What if that guy destroyed his liver through drug abuse or alcoholism? Would you still feel the same way? What if that guy got a liver the next day? What if no one died because of Jobs transplant but he would have died without it? How is that ethical? You don't know anything about the situation but still feel you have the right to condemn someone's decision to save their own life. It's sickening.

By "right thing", I mean asking yourself those questions before using your fortune to exploit a flawed system, rather then just thinking about yourself.


You obviously haven't thought this through at all. Using your logic I shouldn't use employer provided insurance because some people don't have it. I dislike the current system as much as anyone does but to give up on yourself just because it isn't fair to everyone isn't noble it's just stupid.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2