Linked by Thom Holwerda on Mon 14th Dec 2009 15:16 UTC, submitted by chully
Gnome Over the weekend, there has been a bit of a ruffling of the feathers over in the GNOME camp. It started with complaints received about the content on Planet GNOME, and ended with people proposing and organising a vote to split GNOME from the GNU Project.
Permalink for comment 399631
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
wargum
Member since:
2006-12-15


Windows:
* Almost no flexibility in configuration options.

If you are referring to GUI configuration, yes. But that sure has it advantages: Everybody who has used Windows since version 95 can use the next person's Windows as well. No confusion, just start working.

* Ani-malware tools are a requirement.

I disagree. The noobs may need it, companies may need it. Advanced users and power users don't necessarily need it, brain.exe should be sufficent.

* Half my hardware needs drivers that have to be downloaded first.

Get past the XP days, please. Today, in most cases Windows 7 just detects everything and loads the drivers needed via Windows Update.

* No decent window management.

IMHO that is true for pre W7, but Microsoft has done significant improvements in that area for 7 and I like it a lot. My girlfriend is now fully on Windows 7 and trust me, the new taskbar works far better. And one feature that KDE now copies from W7 is very cool: Drag window to a side and it spans to half of the screen width. She uses that quite often, it's very very handy and easy to understand.

* No consistency among applications (menu bar below toolbar here, menu bar above toolbar there, ribbon somewhere else)


Well, Linux is only consistent among apps if you use a small set of poster child apps. My favorite jukebox on Linux is Songbird, it looks totally different to anything else.

KDE/Linux:
* Hardware works out of the box.


Only as long as it decides not to work ;-)
That sure is an argument easily destroyed. If the Kernel version of yours doesn't support a particular component, you are pretty much screwed. And look at different Linux forums, people do have problems and things may break when switching to a newer version of your distribution.

* Major leaps in functionality every six months.


A lot of it is just catch up. You may give some examples.

I've also used Mac OS X for many years. Even Mac OS X 10.3 is still better than recent Windows versions.


Panther was my reason to switch to the Mac. But again, W7 has made huge improvements in usuability, the old thinking doesn't apply here.

Reply Parent Score: 3