Linked by Thom Holwerda on Sun 31st Jan 2010 14:20 UTC, submitted by lemur2
Internet & Networking Despite the recent interest in adopting HTML5's video tag, there is still one major problem: there is no mandated standard video codec for the video tag. The two main contestants are the proprietary and patended h264, and the open and free Theora. In a comment on an article about this problematic situation, LWN reader Trelane posted an email exchange he had with MPEG-LA, which should further cement Theora as the obvious choice.
Permalink for comment 407382
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[6]: costs
by _LH_ on Tue 2nd Feb 2010 10:36 UTC in reply to "RE[5]: costs"
Member since:

If there were older valid patents, prior to circa 1997, belonging to someone else other than On2, which both On2 and the USPTO missed entirely, and which are still valid to this very day, covering some aspect of video compression technology as used in VP3, for which in all this time the owner has never made any demands at all, I would be utterly astounded.

No. When On2 patents part X of VP3, USPTO checks whether there is anything prior related to that patent. If there is another part of VP3, lets call this Y, which On2 has no intentions to patent, then USPTO doesn't even look at that.

The fact that On2 has some patents does prove that those parts of the codec shouldn't be covered by any other patents. But this doesn't tell us anything about the rest of the codec.

To reiterate, USPTO has only checked those parts of the codec that On2 has patented, not the other parts. On the other hand, On2 couldn't possibly have patented the complete codec because even video codecs circa 2000 are very advanced and based on decades' worth of research and prior art. In the technical sense, VP3 isn't very different from recent MPEG codecs.

I must admit that it is unlikely that VP3 has any unknown patents or at least that it isn't any more likely than some other video codec. But yet the patent concern was great enough to make Apple and Nokia vote it out of the HTML5 spec.

Reply Parent Score: 2