Linked by Thom Holwerda on Tue 30th Mar 2010 22:32 UTC, submitted by aaronb
Legal It's time for bed over here, but before I turn in with a nice cup of tea and a Gilmore Girls episode, we've got some good news for you: SCO has been dealt yet another major blow in its baseless lawsuit against Novell. A jury has ruled that Novell owns the UNIX copyrights - not SCO.
Permalink for comment 416202
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[4]: SCO
by Laurence on Wed 31st Mar 2010 14:34 UTC in reply to "RE[3]: SCO"
Laurence
Member since:
2007-03-26

GNU/Linux has the problem of having inconsistent documentation,

That depends on the distribution

breaking drivers (that did work)

As opposed to a lack of drivers on other platforms?

and reinventing the wheel (ALSA, PulseAudio) when there are already good software that could have been built upon.

ALSA and PulseAudio are desktop tools and on the whole Linux is a better desktop OS than BSD or Solaris.

Most of the BSD base system except for things like GCC are now not GNU.

If we're talking about desktop systems then the base system should be transparent to users - which, for the most part, it is on desktop distros (eg Ubuntu). In fact, the very reason I dislike Ubuntu is because I wanted to play with the base system.

However, if we're talking about server systems, then why even mention ALSA / Pulseaudio as I'm struggling to think of any enterprise solutions that would require a soundcard let alone a sane sound driver model.

Furthermore, while BSD can make a perfectly adequate desktop OS (I've had FreeBSD as a working desktop as well as dedicated a file server), Solaris (read vanilla Solaris, NOT OpenSolaris) does not.

And finally, you talk about quality in your OS then go on to discuss BSD desktops, well my experience has taught me that a key quality desktop OSs should have is ease to build and maintain. The ports method on FreeBSD (as much as I loved it for the server) wasn't a patch on pacman (Arch) or apt-get (Debian) in terms of ease and speed of delivery. Sure, you might enjoy tinkering, but most desktop users don't.

Reply Parent Score: 5