Linked by Eugenia Loli on Mon 10th Oct 2005 16:48 UTC, submitted by Shlomi Fish
General Development Shlomi Fish has written a new essay titled "When C is the Best? (Tool for the Job)". Its theme is giving several reasons (besides high speed and low memory consumption) why some code should still be written in C.
Permalink for comment 42737
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Hmmm...
by Anonymous on Mon 10th Oct 2005 20:03 UTC
Anonymous
Member since:
---

There are some comments, but many of them may be out of date. I happen to agree with the Extreme Programming camp that it is really better to refactor and make the code easier to understand than to comment redundantly.

Not keeping comments in sync with the code (either by updating or by deleting them) is just sloppy. Referring to the XP refactoring technique is nothing but a cheap excuse - some code is just too complex to stand without comments, and the threshold for that is much lower than most programmers are comfortable to acknowledge.

This doesn't give me much confidence that Mr. Fish actually knows what he is talking about.

Reply Score: 0