Linked by David Adams on Mon 9th Aug 2010 15:34 UTC, submitted by suka
Gnome Ubuntu's community manager Jono Bacon talks in an interview with derStandard.at about the relationship between Ubuntu and GNOME, GNOME Shell, Unity and why the netbook market is that important to Canonical.
Permalink for comment 435951
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Canonical STILL does not get it
by Fettarme H-Milch on Mon 9th Aug 2010 16:44 UTC
Fettarme H-Milch
Member since:
2010-02-16

Working with GNOME does not mean "Here, we developed XY. If you want it, pick it up yourself from Launchpad."

Working with GNOME means:
1.) Put your ideas up for discussion. Are the proposed additions welcome? If no, can the differences be resolved? Likely the differences are minror.

2.) Develop you stuff in GNOME's git repo. Surely there is some kind of "playground" directory where prototype code is developed.

3.) If your code is permanently rejected, you can still put it up on Launchpad.


Wrt Unity: Was the GNOME team even asked if there is any interest in a netbook shell? I'm not aware of that discussion having taken place.
I'd guess there is interest, but the core team is mostly occupied with GNOME-Shell (which, btw, was proposed by Red Hat pretty much like I described above).

Interestingly while Canonical is hardly known for being a KDE supporter, the two Kubuntu guys do a better job at working with upstream (though it's not really perfect). While their cooperative work could still be better (IMO their libdbusmenu-qt should be hosted in KDE Support, not as separate project on Gitorious), but at least the D-Bus Menu work was actively put upstream to KDE by them.
Granted, their standing is easier, because they built on the 'systray icons via D-Bus' foundation already laid by KDE, so their work was more evolutionary there and not like Canonical's GNOME teams approach "Hey GNOME, we replaced your systray implementation with KDE's protocol. Yeah, we designed it to be completely incompatible with GNOME-Shell, but you can pick it up at Launchpad nonetheless if you want to and port it to GNOME-Shell yourself so we don't have to do the work in a year or so."

Reply Score: 7