Linked by Thom Holwerda on Mon 18th Jun 2012 12:19 UTC
Graphics, User Interfaces It's been one of my major pet peeves on both Android and iOS: the total and utter lack of consistency. Applications - whether first party or third party - all seem to live on islands, doing their own thing, making their own design choices regarding basic UI interactions, developing their own non-standard buttons and controls. Consistency died five years ago, and nobody seems to care but me.
Permalink for comment 522646
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Comment by Radio
by Radio on Mon 18th Jun 2012 14:27 UTC
Radio
Member since:
2009-06-20

Sorry, but I disagree and I wrote a long answer...

Is consistency really necessary to fluidity and ease of use? I do not think so.

-Because the learning phase is short anyway, the cost is not very high.

-We are still inventing new, original way to make an application work. Consistency kills a lot of potential inventivity in UI interaction, especially moving to the rather recent and unexploited touch-based input (think that trackpads did not have multi-touch before! Two-finger scrolling should have been there earlier, instead of the shitty invisible "zones" on the sides of the trackpad).

-I have a really hard time accepting what is implied: that there is out there a "one-size-fits-all" set of UI guidelines. That seems to me a belief without grounds. Sure, it does look sensible; is it? Another illustration that the difference between theory and practice is practice.

-There is another fundamental difference between desktop and mobile computing you overlooked: mobile apps are "glanced at" in a hurry, in a time-out, in-between real-life activities or in the middle of one. The large differences between apps helps me get instantly which one it is. I am sure I launched the right one, and if I come back to my device, I know which one I am looking at or switching to.

Nevertheless, I see the interest in having some core functions of a device being consistent. That is already the case, as Apple and Google usually develop those applications themselves: email, text, contacts, maps, app management, etc.

But would you recriminate against the fact a FPS does not have the same controls than a flight sim or a RTS? Those are all games, aren't they? Why should I relearn how to do things? (Do you see the flaw?)

Reply Score: 8