Linked by Thom Holwerda on Mon 22nd Oct 2012 13:36 UTC
Legal "One of the exhibits Samsung has now made public tells an interesting tale. It's the slide presentation that Apple showed Samsung when it first tried (and failed) to get Samsung to license Apple's patents prior to the start of litigation. While some of the numbers were earlier reported on when the exhibit was used at trial, the slides themselves provide more data - specifically on the difference between what Apple wanted Samsung to pay for Windows phones and for Android phones. The slides punch huge holes in Apple's FRAND arguments. Apple and Microsoft complain to regulators about FRAND rates being excessive and oppressive at approximately $6 per unit, or 2.4%; but the Apple offer was not only at a much higher rate, it targeted Android in a way that seems deliberately designed to destroy its ability to compete in the marketplace." Eagerly awaiting the 45 paragraph comment explaining how this is completely fair and not hypocritical at all. Bonus points if it includes something about Eric Schmidt being on Apple's board, and, double bonus point if it mentions one of the QWERTY Android prototypes. Mega Epic Bonus if it somehow manages to draw a line from Edison, Tesla, to Jobs.
Permalink for comment 539739
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[5]: Apples and oranges
by Alfman on Tue 23rd Oct 2012 20:17 UTC in reply to "RE[4]: Apples and oranges"
Member since:


"Actually, 'reasonable' is a term with a very clear meaning in law - it's chief significance is that it imposes objective limits on what a licensor can charge (i.e., a licensor cannot charge what he subjectively decides he wants to charge). There's been quite a lot written on how it'd operate to restrict the scope of what a licensor can demand in relation to a patent subject to FRAND licensing requirements."

"I can recommend some articles in law journals if you're interested (and have access to a law library)."

I've never read any legal definition of FRAND licensing. If one exists I'd highly appreciate any documentation you can provide/quote to clarify it.

Reply Parent Score: 2