Linked by Thom Holwerda on Fri 20th Jan 2006 21:39 UTC
GNU, GPL, Open Source The update to the GNU GPL 2.0, which was some five years in the making, was released this week for a year of public commentary. Richard Stallman, the founder of the Free Software Foundation and author of the current license, sat down with eWEEK Senior Editor Peter Galli at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology to talk about his aims, hopes and wishes for the new license.
Permalink for comment 88153
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE: DRM is a joke
by tomcat on Sat 21st Jan 2006 19:07 UTC in reply to "DRM is a joke"
Member since:


In every case, every DRM scheme has been cracked by pirates.

DRM isn't supposed to "STOP PIRACY". That's impossible (so you can stop flogging your straw man now). What it's designed to do is increase the cost and hassle to the average person sufficiently that they will choose to conform with the manufacturers' copyright. For example, the average person has no idea how to copy DVDs or pirate cable TV; in order to do that,they have to turn to people who have made it their mission to crack DRM. But not everybody is going to be willing to use cracking software or buy pirate cable boxes because (a) it's illegal and carries steep penalties, (b) it's a hassle, (c) the actual cost of DVDs is pretty low (it's not difficult to find DVD's for $8 or $9 now, so unless your time is worth less than that amount, you're actually wasting money by pirating DVDs), and (d) there are usually quality trade-offs (video artifacts, loss of features, etc) involved in going from mastered media to DVD+/-R that many people will not accept.

Overall CD/movie/content purchasing is way down over the last 2-3 years, and the anti-customer stance of the big corporations is the exact reason why.

It has nothing to do with the "anti-customer stance of the big corporations". It has to do with the fact that CDs lacked DRM -- and ripping is so laughably simple.

But NoooOOOoooo, they go for making their product decidedly worse (by including idiotic DRM) than that which can be shared on the internet (which has no such inconveniences). They are so short sighted and stupid it's laughable.

Here's a fact that blows your argument to shreds: DVD sales have exploded over the past 5 years, despite the fact that they contain DRM.

Reply Parent Score: 1