Linked by Eugenia Loli on Wed 20th Aug 2003 18:44 UTC, submitted by Kelly Samel
Morphos This is a review of the recently released version 1.4 of MorphOS running on the Pegasos computer system written by Kelly Samel of Emerald Imaging.
Permalink for comment
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Re: Clean room
by Don Cox on Thu 21st Aug 2003 19:43 UTC

"I would simply read the following:

http://amiga.emugaming.com/morphoscritics.html"


Yes indeed. This paragraph

"There were *3* books by Dr. Ruprecht with CBM DE blessing which contain a *full documented* resource of most OS 1.3 parts. Most OS structures are public or *were* public. I have all RKMs from 1.1 to 3.1 anyway..not to speak about the Gurubook and all informations CBM ever released to developers.
The whole OS is quite transparent to the *experienced* developers."

confirms what I say. They know far too much about the actual Amiga OS code to make a clean room copy.

But does it matter? The likelihood of Amiga Inc taking it to court is very small, and even then, a court case is a lottery because the lawyers have so little technical knowledge. You may as well toss a coin.

I think the MorphOS team should just carry on doing what they are doing, making a successful successor to AmigaOS, and completely ignore the other side. There's plenty of room in the world for several Amiga-style OSes, just as there is for several UNIX-style OSes.