
OS News' review of Mac OS X last week certainly stirred up controversy, partially because some die hard Mac fans perceived that it was improper for an outsider (someone who is not an everyday Mac user) to me making broad criticisms after only a superficial introduction to the New operating system. Well, folks, that's why they call it a review. We thought that Apple's major new OS also deserved a road test, and there were two very important events in Mac OS X history just a few days ago that toppled the last major obstacle to making it ready for millions of Mac users to start using it as their everyday OS: the 10.1 release and the release of Microsoft Office X. Last week, I made the switch and started using Mac OS X as my everyday OS. Here's how it went:
1. Go into Sherlock and do a search for a file. It takes almost a minute on a stock MacOSX intallation. With BeOS database type filesystem and sub 2 second searches, this is truly unacceptable (and linux and freebsd have similar problems). 2. It seems as if the OS is starved for memory. I know that with todays RAM prices this isn't a problem, but come'on people, 128Mb should be enough (thats the default amount for all iMacs/iBooks. This is what the average user can afford). My iMac thrashes the hard disk like mad (due to paging). 3. The dock is a great innovation, but why in gods name does Apple oppose the widespread use of context menus. They exist in OSX but they're limited. A great implementation of contextual menus is present in BeOS - it absolutely rocks. And what happened to springy folders from the MacOS8x series? 4. ObjC? C'mon people, its the 21st century, C++ has become the defacto language of choice by the whole friggin developer community. The hack that was ObjC should have disappeared in the early 90's. I've read the 250 page PDF introduction to ObjC (from Apples web site, no less) and it has no advantages to C++ (it has a few flaws, actually). Stay with the times, people. And no, Java cannot compete with C++. 5. Finally, Apple hardware is just too damn expensive. I bought an iMac 3 years ago and do not wish to buy Apple hardware again.