Linked by Eugenia Loli-Queru on Tue 9th Dec 2003 22:48 UTC
Gnome A few weeks ago we published an article titled "The Great Mac OS X 10.4 Wish List", detailing a few personal wishes for the next version of OSX. Later I learned that quite a few Apple engineers read the article and so it felt good that the time spent writing the article was not just a voice in the void. A reader emailed me a few days ago asking me to do the same for other OSes and DEs. So here is my personal wish-list for a future version of Gnome. Please tell us about your own Gnome wish list in the comment section provided.
Permalink for comment
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
nice
by Anonymous on Tue 9th Dec 2003 23:40 UTC

Excellent article, you raise many agreeable points.

Aside from a couple things that both kde _and_ gnome could use improvements on, and aside from a couple specific apps you mentioned - it sounds like you want gnome to be more like kde.

I'm guessing that if kde finally got around to creating a theme or two and an icon-set or two that looked a little more "gnomeish", a _lot_ of people would become happy converts. One other thing that I'm pretty certain of, is that much of the gnome-ism comes simply from the fact that it appears to have stronger backing from large companies - so people think it's going to some how be/become more "legit".

I'm using KDE 3.2(beta2/cvs) and it honestly rocks. I was using gnome quite extensively since 2.4 was released, but it just never satisfied, for alot reasons. KDE merely fails to satisfy on a few reasons.

There certainly is more than a couple things that kde definitely can improve on (and it is), but with the release of 3.2, I really think that it just leaped miles ahead gnome, gnome 2.6 will still be behind. And just wait in a couple months when all the kde PIM features that couldn't get released on time w/ the official 3.2 dist are delivered.

One thing KDE could use is a distro that concentrates entirely on pure KDE, one that provides an out-of-the-box default kde experience which attends to some of the vanilla kde issues.

Hopefully you will do another article for a KDE Wish List, if so, please be sure to use the latest 3.2 available to base your wishes.

Cheers! And I hope all your gnome wishes come true!