Linked by Kevin Arvin on Thu 1st Jan 2004 21:29 UTC
The aim of this experimental Linux distribution is to provide to the student population at large an operating system that is easy to install and use and provides an alternative to the traditional commercial operating systems. CollegeLinux is a Slackware derived Linux (2.4.23) distribution on a single CD that weighs in at 600 MB.
Permalink for comment
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
"Please allow me to disagree. Review is the written/said description of a personal experience. As such, if the reviewer (see: user) doesn't like a theme, he is free to say it. Of course it is subjective."
If it was, he didn't made it clear. He just quoted his opinion with IMO "IMO, it seems to be the best of the..." but not on the spicy comments.
"If you think that reviews are "feature listings", you are wrong. These are also called "press releases" and they are not reviews."
Aheam, it might come as a surprise but I hardly need to be reminded of the difference between a press release or an hype shoot and a fair review. Just in case you are interested this was a real review:
http://www.newsforge.com/os/03/05/27/1514225.shtml
The author at newsforge did pointed out the positive and negative aspects of CL yet respecting the authors of a small, volunteers baded and free distribution.
Eugenia, Please don't get me wrong. I do have a grea deal of respect for you and all your authors. I am grateful to OSnews for the support.
That said it takes two to tango. I can certainly accept every form of constructive criticism but if I have to deal with such a review, he should deal with my comments.
Once again thanks for your understanding and support.
Regards
David
P.S. Following your kind suggestion I won't reply to his comments.
"Please allow me to disagree. Review is the written/said description of a personal experience. As such, if the reviewer (see: user) doesn't like a theme, he is free to say it. Of course it is subjective."
If it was, he didn't made it clear. He just quoted his opinion with IMO "IMO, it seems to be the best of the..." but not on the spicy comments.
"If you think that reviews are "feature listings", you are wrong. These are also called "press releases" and they are not reviews."
Aheam, it might come as a surprise but I hardly need to be reminded of the difference between a press release or an hype shoot and a fair review. Just in case you are interested this was a real review:
http://www.newsforge.com/os/03/05/27/1514225.shtml
The author at newsforge did pointed out the positive and negative aspects of CL yet respecting the authors of a small, volunteers baded and free distribution.
Eugenia, Please don't get me wrong. I do have a grea deal of respect for you and all your authors. I am grateful to OSnews for the support.
That said it takes two to tango. I can certainly accept every form of constructive criticism but if I have to deal with such a review, he should deal with my comments.
Once again thanks for your understanding and support.
Regards
David
P.S. Following your kind suggestion I won't reply to his comments.