Linked by Alejandro Tamayo Castillo on Wed 20th Oct 2004 18:48 UTC
Talk, Rumors, X Versus Y In this article I will analyze the features and costs to select which is the best operating system for servers as well as the services that each one of them brings to us.
Permalink for comment
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Oh dear....
by Archangel on Wed 20th Oct 2004 22:32 UTC

I'm gonna have to chime in too. That's got to be one of the least professional articles I've seen - sorry to the author, but it's the truth. There's nothing but opinion backing up all of those numbers.

To take a few examples:
System Maintenance. 5 to Windows? You LIKE having to reboot the entire server to install updates, and having to do it constantly?

And 3 to Windows for security makes me question what exactly would get 2, 1 or 0? It's the most exploited OS available - therefore it should be at the bottom of the scale. Of course there are official sites saying how secure it is - that's called advertising! Those of us not employed by MS are meant to be able to see through such things.

Amount of services and commercial applications: Not generally that crucial a factor on a server - you generally have everything you need unless you're after something pretty esoteric.

Anyway that's enough.... I suppose I sound pretty irritated. Mostly your article sounded strongly Microsoft-biased - it seems to have played very much to their strengths (Active Directory etc) and glossed over the weaknesses (security & patches).