Linked by Adam S on Sat 17th Jun 2006 03:07 UTC, submitted by chr1skearney
Apple Many people who have called Apple to complain about excessive heat coming from their newly purchased computers have been told that the MacBook and the MacBook Pro are in fact Notebook computers and not Laptop computers. This article details why they are totally full of it.
Thread beginning with comment 135011
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE
by alcibiades on Mon 19th Jun 2006 06:34 UTC in reply to "RE"
alcibiades
Member since:
2005-10-12

The main point Simba is making is right and does not depend on the particular layout of this particular machine.

There is a reason why a company has a long term record of heat/noise problems. Apple has had far too many for it to be explicable as an accident. The pattern at work is the triumph of lifestyle marketing over industrial design. Sometimes it leads to the noise of a jet engine taking off coming from a floorstander. Sometimes it leads to overheating.

Take a look at the Antec 180, and compare it to the Apple floorstanders. The Antec was designed by people who wanted the quietest, coolest, simplest to work on case they could make. The Mac was designed to impress people who know very little about hardware and who will buy it without hearing it running.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1

RE
by mungas on Mon 19th Jun 2006 08:26 in reply to "RE"
mungas Member since:
2006-05-08

The G4 QS or MD had noise problems, but most computers from Dell sound worse.

Is the G5 case small?
Is the G5 case missing air vents?
Have you ever used a Mac?

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1

RE
by collywolly on Mon 19th Jun 2006 12:09 in reply to "RE"
collywolly Member since:
2006-06-19

but most computers from Dell sound worse.
Most computers from Dell cost a fraction of the price.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1

RE: How did Dell bashing get on this thread?
by cogx on Mon 19th Jun 2006 16:54 in reply to "RE"
cogx Member since:
2006-06-19

The G4 QS or MD had noise problems, but most computers from Dell sound worse.

It of course depends on what model you have and also what video card one has chosen. A Dell Dimension with a gaming video card is going to be far noisier system than the Optiplex line with a passively-cooled video option, especially the very quiet small-form factor chassis. (Not that Dell doesn't have their own hardware "issues", believe me, but that's an entirely different discussion for some other time perhaps.)

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1