Linked by Thom Holwerda on Wed 28th Jun 2006 22:23 UTC
GNU, GPL, Open Source Could many smaller Linux distributions be in violation of the GPL? That's what Warren Woodford, the man behind the popular MEPIS distribution thinks. As detailed in Bruce Byfield's excellent NewsForge story, "A GPL requirement could have a chilling effect on derivative distro", Woodford recently ran afoul of the GNU GPL (General Public License) requirement that downstream distributors of GPL code are obligated to provide source code to users in an easily accessible format.
Thread beginning with comment 138341
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
why woodford?
by Terracotta on Wed 28th Jun 2006 23:06 UTC
Terracotta
Member since:
2005-08-15

He uses the ubuntu repositories, I don't see why he has to provide the sources of those packages? As long as his own repositories have the sources of everything that's in his repository it should be fine I think.

RE: why woodford?
by howard on Wed 28th Jun 2006 23:17 in reply to "why woodford?"
howard Member since:
2006-01-08

Because Woodford distributed the binaries under the GPL.

It's simple. Anyone who uses the GPL to distribute binaries must also offer the source. If Woodford wants someone else to provide the source, then he should also have them provide the binaries.

He has the source. Why didn't he offer it?

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 3

RE[2]: why woodford?
by thebluesgnr on Wed 28th Jun 2006 23:20 in reply to "RE: why woodford?"
thebluesgnr Member since:
2005-11-14

He did.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1

RE[2]: why woodford?
by bytecoder on Wed 28th Jun 2006 23:49 in reply to "RE: why woodford?"
bytecoder Member since:
2005-11-27

He shouldn't need to offer it--it was already available.

Honestly, this is one more reason I dislike the GPL.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 0

RE: why woodford?
by historyb on Wed 28th Jun 2006 23:20 in reply to "why woodford?"
historyb Member since:
2005-07-06

He orginally never released the sources for Mepis in the beginning. Weather he was ignorant of the GPL at the time or he didn't care is debatable.

He's upset so he want's others to feel his pain I guess

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2

RE[2]: why woodford?
by raver31 on Thu 29th Jun 2006 00:55 in reply to "RE: why woodford?"
raver31 Member since:
2005-07-06

I concur, I think that guy Woodford has serious problems.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 3