Linked by Thom Holwerda on Thu 7th Sep 2006 20:56 UTC, submitted by thebluesgnr
Thread beginning with comment 160434
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE[3]: How does it compare to SLED?
by thebluesgnr on Fri 8th Sep 2006 10:26
in reply to "RE[2]: How does it compare to SLED?"
RE[4]: How does it compare to SLED?
by g2devi on Fri 8th Sep 2006 11:36
in reply to "RE[3]: How does it compare to SLED?"
dagw is correct according to good system design, the root password should not be required until the last minute. I don't use SUSE or YaST, but if YaST is designed properly, it would would in a way analogous to this: If a module requires root permissions to use any functionality at all or view any status, that module should be displayed anyway in a list and when you click on it you'll get a request for a root password.
RE[4]: How does it compare to SLED?
by dagw on Fri 8th Sep 2006 12:28
in reply to "RE[3]: How does it compare to SLED?"







Member since:
2005-07-06
About YaST; when you launch it from a non root account it doesn't ask for a root password, so you can do pretty much nothing from it.
It does(or at least did) however ask you for the root password the first time you try to do something that requires one. I consider this a good and sensible approach. First of all in a multi user envitonment most users don't know the root password so being able to open YaST and see everything they can do without a root password is a good thing. Secondly I personally think that in general asking for the root should be done at the last possible moment. As in only when I actually try to view or write to a file I don't have permission for.