Linked by Nathan J. Hill on Tue 24th Oct 2006 10:43 UTC
Linspire In the midst of the busy semester here at school, my fiancee's laptop, running Windows XP SP2, picked up some friends - adware, trojans, etc. It was a pretty nasty sight. I worked on it for at least two hours every couple of days, wiping it clean, doing my best to lock it down, and so on. Avast! and Ad-Aware had their limits it seemed, for only a day or so after I cleaned it, pop-ups and weird stuff would show up again. She was getting sick of it. I was getting sick of cleaning it, so I suggested, offhand, installing a different operating system that is a bit more impervious to those nasties. To my surprise, she agreed.
Thread beginning with comment 174605
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
About beeing too far from Windows
by ulhume on Tue 24th Oct 2006 12:01 UTC
Member since:

First, I never tried Lispire. I must confess that I don't have a good feeling about it, but Distros are like religions, I never question about them.

You wrote "I didn't want to stray too far away from basic Windows-like capabilitie". The problem is linux is not windows in any way. I have the same respect for windows than with any linux distro (same religion point ;-). Ok, you have icons, keyboard and mouse on the screen, but that's quite all.

My fiancee also switched to linux, 2 years ago, and she's not a technical-computing person at all. But she switched cleanly the day I understood that I have to explain all the differences. When I gave up with my fear of "linux too complex for her, let's be simple". Linux is not that complex, and Windows is not that simple, from a new player point of view.

So I explained her everything from scratch. What is Linux way of installing a software, seeking information, storing documents, etc.. And from this day, she was not any more a "Windows person trying to figure out what was going one" but a "Linux user, following step by step her lurning curve in a NEW system".

The problem about "Linux Desktop" is that everyone really want it to be a "smooth move". But what is the point of moving from one system to another if you don't think it is a better one for your use ? And what is the point of using a better system if you don't learn first how different it is. Perhaps Linux is not a better system for her, perhaps MacOS is the right choice. I really don't know and I'm not judging. But one thing I know for sure. This "fashion" to turn a Linux into a windows to "help" user, is just not helping at all ! It's not helping Linux itself and definitely not helping users.

PS: About korean input method, I didn't try but it was quite easy to add vietnameese input to her laptop. It was just fonts, a package for input driver. And about Wireless network did you try ndis-wrapper, a good solution to use Windows drivers in Linux with same level of capabilities.

Edited 2006-10-24 12:13

Reply Score: 5

intangible Member since:

There needs to be a rating higher than 5 for your comment.

I also wonder why the author wanted to make Linux as Windows-like as possible for his fiance but didn't mind changing the interface completely for her with OS X... It seems a bit like a double-standard to me.

Reply Parent Score: 5

aquila_deus Member since:

CJK text need special input systems, not just font or keyboard driver.

EDIT: none of CJK input systems I know directly supports KDE, maybe that is the problem.

Edited 2006-10-25 08:00

Reply Parent Score: 1