Linked by Thom Holwerda on Mon 13th Nov 2006 08:46 UTC, submitted by someone
Java The cat is out of the bag: Java will be released under the GPL. Joshua Marinacci writes: "I think it makes a lot of sense because it protects Sun's interest in preventing forks and also the community's interest in knowing that Java will forever be available in the public sphere. The GPL has always provided an option to fork just in case someone takes the code in a bad direction. Historically having this option available ensures that it never needs to actually be used, letting the community grow and thrive."
Thread beginning with comment 181901
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
My fear
by suryad on Mon 13th Nov 2006 20:12 UTC
suryad
Member since:
2005-07-09

...is how it is going to be decided what code is going to go in and what is going to be rejected. I mean in the iedal world, going open source and gpl'd and all that means there is now a much easier access of the code by hugely talented programmers. But is there going to be a body finally that will decide what goes in and what doesnt? A colleague of mine asked me why they didnt go with ASF (Apache Software Foundation) because they have a very well known track record for producing excellent quality code. Does it mean that GPLing the code means anyone can get access to it but that if someone wants to add the next hot feature, Sun and its JCP still will have the final say? Sorry if I got my terminology etc incorrect. Just trying to understand. Thanks.

RE: My fear
by santana on Mon 13th Nov 2006 20:31 in reply to "My fear"
santana Member since:
2006-10-22

Yep, JCP and Sun will have the last word. For now. And that is a good thing. You really don't want every programmer under the sun to put what he/she likes in Java. However, that JCP and Sun governance will have to morph into something more practical down the road (if too many people are unhappy with the way Sun/JCP lead things, they will fork).

On why Apache wasn't choosen; first of all, it doesn't play well with GPL (read, Linux). Second, you don't have to give code back.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1

RE: My fear
by holywood on Mon 13th Nov 2006 21:50 in reply to "My fear"
holywood Member since:
2006-09-25

This is what happening for every project.

If the owner of the project doesn't find your code will fit in their ideal, they won't add it to the main branch.

But, if you want it, you can fork the project and add it !

Sorry for my English.

(I can be wrong too!)

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2