Linked by Thom Holwerda on Mon 8th Jan 2007 15:22 UTC, submitted by anonymous
ReactOS The new ReactOS newsletter has been published. "Currently the main development branch "trunk" even though it has many new features and bug fixes since 0.3.0, it currently has several issues that prevent it from being relatively useful. Furthermore functionality that once worked no longer does, this is called a regression. Until trunk has been reasonably fixed 0.3.1 will not be released. Be assured that the developers are working hard on fixing the current issues and bringing forth a good public release as soon as humanly possible."
Thread beginning with comment 199493
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Even after reading...
by Tuishimi on Mon 8th Jan 2007 16:00 UTC
Tuishimi
Member since:
2005-07-06

...the ReactOS "What is ReactOS" I am not 100% sure of the reason behind the project. I understand the usefulness of wine for linux users, but recreating the ubiquitous desktop seems sort of fruitless, as every PC out there comes with it "real thing" bundled into it. There are open source and freeware tools that can be used in lieu of MS tools for many things that run on Windows already.

I'm not saying I don't LIKE the idea of the project... Just that it seems like it is being done just because it can be done, which is fine too.

RE: Even after reading...
by zizban on Mon 8th Jan 2007 16:03 in reply to "Even after reading..."
zizban Member since:
2005-07-06

The idea behind it is to make an open source Windows clone. There are people that like Windows but dont like Linux. Back in the day, Unix was great but expensive and restricted thus GNU/Linux was born. There is an open source BeOS clone. People have varied tastes and you have to respect that.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 2

RE: Even after reading...
by Clinton on Mon 8th Jan 2007 16:04 in reply to "Even after reading..."
Clinton Member since:
2005-07-05

I'm not sure I get it either.

First off, it seems like the minute they release, they'll be sued out of existence, and secondly, in all honesty, whose going to want to use something that is compatible with a 10+ year old OS?

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: -1

RE[2]: Even after reading...
by umccullough on Mon 8th Jan 2007 16:17 in reply to "RE: Even after reading..."
umccullough Member since:
2006-01-26

whose going to want to use something that is compatible with a 10+ year old OS?

I would.

The last thing I *WANT* with my windows machine is to be forced to upgrade to Vista - I'd like to keep running windows 2000 or windows xp (i find both to be pretty much the same in actual usefulness) for a long time yet.

If an FOSS version of those were to an option - I'd switch to them ;)

Edit: Nevermind that Microsoft themselves has been making every version of windows "compatible with a 10+ year old OS" and succeeding at it pretty effectively so far.

Edited 2007-01-08 16:18

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 5

RE[2]: Even after reading...
by Adam S on Mon 8th Jan 2007 16:32 in reply to "RE: Even after reading..."
Adam S Member since:
2005-04-01

I want to run certain Windows apps on my mac. If I can install ReactOS, I can run it virtually and then run my apps on top of it, all for free.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1

RE[2]: Even after reading...
by BluenoseJake on Tue 9th Jan 2007 16:29 in reply to "RE: Even after reading..."
BluenoseJake Member since:
2005-08-11

They can't be sued out of existence, as long as they don't use original Windows code. If eveything is reverse engineered, then there is no problem, just like Samba or Wine

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1

Answer...
by frik85 on Mon 8th Jan 2007 16:22 in reply to "Even after reading..."
frik85 Member since:
2006-01-26

Which of our "What is ReactOS" have you read? We have one short one in the FAQ page and another more detailed article labled with the same headline:

http://www.reactos.org/en/about_whatisreactos.html
http://www.reactos.org/en/about_userfaq.html

ReactOS is an advanced free open source operating system providing a ground-up implementation of a Microsoft Windows XP compatible operating system. ReactOS aims to achieve complete binary compatibility with both applications and device drivers meant for NT and XP operating systems, by using a similar architecture and providing a complete and equivalent public interface. ReactOS has and will continue to incorporating features from newer versions and sometimes even define the state of the art in operating system technology.

Linux has been the open source answer to closed source Unix (Xenix, IRIX & co.). ReactOS is the answer to WinNT/VMS series (which also covers WinXP/Vista, etc.).

It's pretty simple, it's always good to have alternatives. A lot of people are annoyed by operating systems which restrict their usage, come with inbuilt DRM, restrictive licenses, OSs that are resource hogs, etc.
ReactOS has been started in 1996, before all these topics were relevant. The ideas behind ReactOS are pretty similar like the Linux movement. The only major different is that ReactOS is a whole operating system were Linux is only the kernel (and kernel-libs).

And please don't forget the big masses of WinNT series compatible drivers and Win32 software and there is only one OS out there beside Redmond based monopol which support that; ReactOS.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 5

RE: Even after reading...
by arielb on Mon 8th Jan 2007 17:05 in reply to "Even after reading..."
arielb Member since:
2006-11-15

ReactOS is a good thing for other open source OS's. There's a tendency for open source advocates to copy Windows just so Windows users can switch to free software. But if that's the job for reactos, then there is no need for other OS's to lose their identity.

KDE is moving to Windows...but that could then lead to KDE on ReactOS. And then people might move to KDE on desktopbsd or linux. In other words, it's a good bridge to another OS. It's an incremental approach

I think the first people who might switch to reactos are the litestep fans. Also people would stop pirating Windows, especially in the 3rd world. They would just use this instead and still get support because it's legit.

Reply Parent Bookmark Score: 1