To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Even GNOME with Nautilus is pretty cheap nowadays. The big DEs have mostly figured out where they hog memory and have begun to address these issues. Nautilus takes 13MB on my system, just barely edging out the weather applet.
If you really like your "lightweight" desktop, then go for it. But if your reasoning is that you want a lightweight desktop, then either you're trying to make do with 256MB of RAM, or you're kidding yourself.
Even GNOME with Nautilus is pretty cheap nowadays. The big DEs have mostly figured out where they hog memory and have begun to address these issues. Nautilus takes 13MB on my system, just barely edging out the weather applet.
If you really like your "lightweight" desktop, then go for it. But if your reasoning is that you want a lightweight desktop, then either you're trying to make do with 256MB of RAM, or you're kidding yourself.
I am not talking about just RAM. I am talking about speed. I am talking about quick redraw. I am talking about seeing the borders of the window I am dragging only once, and not twenty times.
I can have 768MB in my Celeron (not M) laptop, and I do, but it won't make the thing fast. None of the problems above did I experience under Windows, at least not to the extent I saw when I was using Gnome. That's why I changed to KDE (and tried Enlightenment and XFCE before), and it's much better now, but I still believe that the main problem is the slowness of GUI toolkits, and that does not seem to go away soon.
P.S. I know there is FLTK, but I have yet to see a serious application that uses it.
Edited 2007-03-05 08:37





Member since:
2006-09-02
My thoughts exactly. One of the reasons for my switch to Linux was (aside from being free, of course) E17. It looked so nice, I just had to try it
But then I did, and as much as I liked it, I just couldn't see where it was heading, or rather, WHEN it will arrive there.
And as for "lightweight environment": I found that it does not really matter THAT much. Every application uses either Qt or GTK anyway, so there goes any attempt at being lightweight on the Linux desktop... Of course, I would never use Gnome with Nautilus handling the desktop on my laptop, but aside from that, it's really all the same.