Linked by Thom Holwerda on Mon 19th Mar 2007 19:37 UTC, submitted by Hiev
X11, Window Managers "Desktop computing technology has evolved considerably since the first graphical user interface was developed by researchers at Xerox's Palo Alto Research Center in 1973. Microsoft's Aero Glass, Apple's Quartz 2D Extreme, and Sun's Project Looking Glass are all poised to transform the way that users interact with computers. Also at the forefront of innovation, the Linux community has some prodigiously impressive new user interface technologies of its own. Beryl, a new open-source window manager for Linux, features compelling visual enhancements like support for transparent windows and elaborate window animations."
Thread beginning with comment 222569
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Good
by Duffman on Mon 19th Mar 2007 20:02 UTC
Duffman
Member since:
2005-11-23

I haven't to waste some time to comment this, someone on the arstechnica forum already did

And OK, so you can make your windows animate away however you want. Whoopy-de-doo. Yeah, I really want my windows to disappear in a very intensive flame effect, or explode to pieces. This looks like effects found in bad home-movie editing software (ever seen something a kid created in Microsoft Movie Maker? heh).

Reply Score: 1

RE: Good
by Bit_Rapist on Mon 19th Mar 2007 20:11 in reply to "Good"
Bit_Rapist Member since:
2005-11-13

I haven't to waste some time to comment this, someone on the arstechnica forum already did

And OK, so you can make your windows animate away however you want. Whoopy-de-doo. Yeah, I really want my windows to disappear in a very intensive flame effect, or explode to pieces. This looks like effects found in bad home-movie editing software (ever seen something a kid created in Microsoft Movie Maker? heh).


If thats all you can come up with then I don't think you've really spent any decent time using Beryl.

Those effects can be turned off and there are some nice usability aspects to the software such as the 'expose' style window selection.

Reply Parent Score: 5

RE: Good
by Seth Quarrier on Mon 19th Mar 2007 20:24 in reply to "Good"
Seth Quarrier Member since:
2005-11-13

This project is good for the open source desktop regardless of wether you use it or not. It gives provides a set of features that are available in all of the competitors and not having this around would cause a deluge of complaints from Windows and Mac fanboys that would be far more annoying than people talking about how they like some eye candy that you don't care for.

You don't have to install it (I don't have it installed) and you are free to ignore it but be glad that it exists.

Reply Parent Score: 5

RE[2]: Good
by Doc Pain on Mon 19th Mar 2007 21:31 in reply to "RE: Good"
Doc Pain Member since:
2006-10-08

"This project is good for the open source desktop regardless of wether you use it or not. It gives provides a set of features that are available in all of the competitors and not having this around would cause a deluge of complaints from Windows and Mac fanboys that would be far more annoying than people talking about how they like some eye candy that you don't care for."

Home users who want to buy a PC (or an OS) are usually looking at how it looks like: window manager, effects, desktop, icons, menues etc. So Beryl could be promoting Linux OSes in a very good way. The visual experience is the first one and the most impressive one. Especially live system CDs featuring Beryl along with Linux offer something you won't find in "Windows": You don't need to install anything, you can test and try out. And if you think, well, KDE is fine as it is, I don't like Beryl at all, so don't install it. But at least Beryl is very impressive as long as you have the hardware specification it needs.

"You don't have to install it (I don't have it installed) and you are free to ignore it but be glad that it exists."

I'd say the same.

Reply Parent Score: 4

Fanboyism
by s_groening on Mon 19th Mar 2007 21:41 in reply to "RE: Good"
s_groening Member since:
2005-12-13

Why is it that we have to read this sort of comments about users of other OSs all the time?

Is it really soooo incomprehensible to so many people that not every one uses the same OS and that there might be reasons for using Windows, Mac OS X, Linux, *BSD - you name it - without having to refer to people as zealots, fanboys and the likes that indicate people with no will of their own??

To be honest, it annoys me...

Reply Parent Score: 2

RE: Good
by Sphinx on Mon 19th Mar 2007 23:39 in reply to "Good"
Sphinx Member since:
2005-07-09

Really sets a new low there, copy a lame stupid troll from someone else and then not even giving the ass credit.

Reply Parent Score: 5