Linked by Thom Holwerda on Fri 8th Jun 2007 15:01 UTC, submitted by AdministratorX
Microsoft In its second such agreement this week, Microsoft has struck a deal under which it will extend amnesty to a company that's using what the software maker claims is patented Microsoft intellectual property embedded in the open source Linux computer operating system. Under a deal with LG Electronics, disclosed late Wednesday, Microsoft will forgo any Linux-related patent claims against the South Korean electronics manufacturer. In return, Microsoft will gain access to certain intellectual property produced by LG.
Thread beginning with comment 246253
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Breaking story...
by fretinator on Fri 8th Jun 2007 15:21 UTC
fretinator
Member since:
2005-07-06

A scene at the local Linux Software Store:

Microsoft: So, we're not planning on goin' after anybody for patents, ya see. We're just here to ...uh... make sure nothing bad happens to you. AFter all, we're all like family here, ya see?

Vendor: [Smiles nervously] Yes, family. Um, what are you asking of me?

Microsoft: Well, my boys have written up a little deal here that says we won't come after you for any of dat Patent business, ya see. You just sign here that you agree, and everybody's happy. You're safe. Everybody's safe. Capice?

Vendor: Yessir, but, um, what is it I am doing that I need protection from? Have I done something wrong?

Microsoft: [Bangs the counter with fist] Wrong. Right. Everybody's wrong, everybody's right. All I'm saying is there's a little trouble brewing around this here patent stuff, and you wouldn't wanna be on the wrong side, you know. As I said, we're on your side. Let's just write it down, OK? [Menacing glare]

Vendor: OK, family. I get it. Do you want some of my software? I have very good software.

Microsoft: Sure, sure. Send me a present. I like presents. I have some for you, too. See, now we're friends. [pats Vendor on the cheek]

Vendor: [Signs document]. Friend, come back soon. [Eyes look down]

Microsoft: Sure, sure. I'll check back now and then to make sure you're doing OK. And ... tell you're friends!

Reply Score: 5

RE: Breaking story...
by sappyvcv on Fri 8th Jun 2007 15:37 in reply to "Breaking story..."
sappyvcv Member since:
2005-07-06

That's a poor analogy. In this case, Microsoft is not threatening LG, but in fact promising, under contract, to not sue them and also paying them for access to some of their intellectual property.

The way you make it out to be, LG would be paying Microsoft, which is simply not true.

Reply Parent Score: 4

RE[2]: Breaking story...
by fretinator on Fri 8th Jun 2007 15:42 in reply to "RE: Breaking story..."
fretinator Member since:
2005-07-06

No, the point of the story is nobody's paying anybody. If any software is exchanged (such as with Novell), it's just incidental. The key is the signed contract and the supposed "protection" being offered.

Reply Parent Score: 5

RE[2]: Breaking story...
by archiesteel on Fri 8th Jun 2007 16:40 in reply to "RE: Breaking story..."
archiesteel Member since:
2005-07-02

Microsoft is not threatening LG, but in fact promising, under contract, to not sue them


It's an implicit threat:

MS: "We won't sue if you accept this contract."
Other company: "And if we don't?"
MS: "Do you really want to find out?"
Other company: "Ok, where do I sign."

This is all part of MS's new FUD offensive against Linux.

Reply Parent Score: 5

RE[2]: Breaking story...
by Phloptical on Fri 8th Jun 2007 22:50 in reply to "RE: Breaking story..."
Phloptical Member since:
2006-10-10

Uhh, but it is...actually. Threats...promises...what's the difference, the end result? Microsoft is benefiting, albeit freely, from LG's IP. That would be akin to being paid for items/services they don't own (ie. protection money).

You really need to watch some mob shows to see how this thing is done properly.

Reply Parent Score: 2