To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Just out of curiosity - given the Nvidia 8600 a go with *NIX? it would be interesting to see what/how it performs - especially with Solaris.
Regarding "Pure Video" I assume that is a Windows only feature - they haven't/won't make it available using OpenGL on supported *NIX platforms :-(
Actually, it's not unfair at all. You see, the article simply shows what happens when you upgrade an older PC. You see, it is NOT clear that if you upgrade a graphics card you will get so much better rendering times and video playback. Sure, you will get better 3D performance, but multimedia is NOT clear to everyone out there that it will be faster. And this is why I wrote the review: because I wanted to show to fellow videographers or even casual HD enthusiasts who don't use NLEs or apps that support GL, that they can clearly benefit from a newer card. I am pretty sure that a newer ATI card will perform equally well in the multimedia front: it's just that I have no way of testing it.
Hence, I find my article pretty clear as to what it was trying to achieve: a WAKE UP CALL to fellow media users. I know video semi-professionals who use an Intel card with their Adobe Premiere!!! I really hope that this article wakes them up because there is significant speeds up to be gained from a gaming card, even if your media app doesn't support Quadro GL or whatever other similar PRO card!
I am not sure how more clear this can be written as.
Edited 2007-07-19 10:47
Going by your analogy, you're displaying a bias towards Ford. It's no different from the people who accuse ArsTechnica of having an "anti-Mac" bias - when, if anything, they simply have an "anti-bullshit" bias. A decided lack of context is demonstrated by the failure to realize that the same standards are applied to all their reviews - not simply those of Apple products.
Here's a rather telling question: would you have had the same objections if the comparison had *not* been made to an ATI card, but rather to an nVidia card of the same vintage?








Member since:
2005-06-29
Out with guns blazing!
You're serious? She said that it was her old card. It was just a smallish review on how nice the speed bump is with the new more RECENT video card. And there you had to crucify her for something she never intentionaly meant to do.