Linked by Thom Holwerda on Mon 20th Aug 2007 21:09 UTC
Linspire "Freespire, the free as in beer version of the Linspire Linux distribution, this month released Freespire 2.0, the first version of the operating system based on the popular Ubuntu distribution, and the first to contain proprietary codecs and drivers. Despite its attractive appearance, it left me with mixed feelings."
Thread beginning with comment 264752
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
RE: Poor review
by netpython on Tue 21st Aug 2007 10:05 UTC in reply to "Poor review"
Member since:

I guarentee you this, if using the nvidea driver and other changes requires editing a config file NONE of its intended userbase will ever do so

That alone defeats the goal targeted.

Reply Parent Score: 3

RE[2]: Poor review
by Robocoastie on Tue 21st Aug 2007 16:04 in reply to "RE: Poor review"
Robocoastie Member since:

Well that's not Linspire's fault at all. It's a known issue in Ubuntu as well with Nvidia cards because the recent driver doesn't detect people's monitors very well. Perhaps its simply because there's so many types of monitors out there. I ended up digging through my monitor makers website to find the information to change the V and H rates, then added my resolutions and it worked.

I really don't know how Linspire could fix that. The only way is probably for OEM's to sell only equipment that the drivers are known to correctly identify. I've thought for some time anyway that a Linux oem should try to build and sell equipment for Linux then only support their equipment ala Apple. That or the largest distros like Ubuntu, and OpenSuse have a program where equipment makers can put a Tux sticker on it to indicate it works out of the box with *nix.

Reply Parent Score: 1

RE[3]: Poor review
by da_Chicken on Tue 21st Aug 2007 18:10 in reply to "RE[2]: Poor review"
da_Chicken Member since:

Debian (and, hence, also Ubuntu and Freespire) includes a debconf script for configuring Xorg. From the command line you can run this script by typing "dpkg-reconfigure xserver-xorg" as root (or add sudo to the beginning in Ubuntu & Freespire). Debconf can be configured to use a GUI (gtk or qt) frontend by typing "dpkg-reconfigure debconf" ("sudo dpkg-reconfigure debconf").

There's also a GUI frontend to this dpkg-reconfigure command, called gkdebconf. In Ubuntu you can find gkdebconf in the "universe" repo. To make gkdebconf look a bit nicer, GNOME users can also install the libgnome2-perl package and KDE users should install libqt-perl.

Freespire could install gkdebconf by default and add it to their menu, so users don't need to touch the command line. Of course, you need to know the technical details of your hardware before you can successfully configure Xorg even via a GUI tool. The next Xorg release (or is it the next xserver-xorg release?) should add an improved autodetection of display hardware, and this is probably the ideal solution to Xorg configuration problems.

I also noticed that Ubuntu plans to add a new GUI tool for configuring some Xorg settings, like the graphics driver, screen resolution and the number of monitors. Apparently this new GUI tool is not ready for common use yet.

The Ion window manager seems like a strange choice in Freespire. It's easy on the system resources but new Linux users might find Ion a bit difficult, I suspect. Ion is great if you learn the keybindings but it's not exactly designed for point-and-click use.

Reply Parent Score: 5