To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
First of all congratulations! OSNews is one of the best news sites for OS and software related topics, especially if you are interested in free software.
However, I do think that OSNews isn't as good as it used to be. This is not the fault of the comment system or OSNews site, but of the OSNews users. The problem is that some people can't follow the moderation guidlines.
They vote things down because they don't agree with the contents, not because it is offensive or off topic but because they disagree as the guidlines suggests.
The start of this thread is a good example of this. It contained no offensive language and saying the comment was off topic was a bit of a stretch. Still it currently is rated -4.
So please, if you come across comments that you don't agree with, don't vote them down. Instead tell us why you don't agree. Who knows, sometimes you might even convince the other person and others that he is wrong. Just voting it down makes the voting system useless for selecting comments worth to read.
The community ?
I don't think there is a single community at OSn - several IMO .
IMO the topics are broad enough to attract several types of folk .
If there was one community then we'd all participate equally in the different topics posted .
Those commenting on programming languages won't neccessarilty be interested at all in the latest OSX beta build - for example .
IMO the different groups are good & bad - good mix but also sometimes mindless flamewars .








Member since:
2005-07-10
I was a regular on OSNews but their comment system is really bad. It suppresses the voice of minority. So i rarely visit this site. Now i mostly hang out on Digg. Even though digg has similar commenting system but viewing modded down comments is far easier and the community is less GPL fanatic.