To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
Knoppix is not and was never installable.
Wrong. My first successful Debian installation (back in the Debian Woody days) was done via Knoppix. The installation was simple and quick -- it just created a new file system and then dumped the contents of the live-cd onto the hard drive (kind of like the current Ubuntu desktop installer does).
The problem was that Knoppix mixed packages from Debian Stable, Testing, and Unstable, plus many packages from unofficial repositories, and the first "apt-get dist-upgrade" immediately broke my installation. 
How can this be modded up where it is obviously false? Knoppix was installable off the live CD for the longest time. There was an option within the booted system from where you could start a HD install. It even had/has (?) a feature where you could set it up to act as a thin client server.
Knoppix was indeed installable, but that didn't lead to a very stable installation. Kanotix, a Knoppix deriviate focussed on installation, should imho qualify as the first properly installable livecd. There was of course a lot of cooparation between kanotix/knoppix, and I think the installation tools and stuff from kanotix got merged back in knoppix, so it is properly installable nowadays.
Knoppix was indeed installable, but that didn't lead to a very stable installation. Kanotix, a Knoppix deriviate focussed on installation, should imho qualify as the first properly installable livecd.
I checked the DistroWatch page for Kanotix and it seems that Kanotix was started sometime in the late 2004. But in the early 2003 there was already an installable live-cd called Morphix. It used only packages from Debian Sid and there were three versions: one with XFCE, one with GNOME, and one with KDE. Morphix had a nice-looking GUI installer and at that time I found Morphix an ideal way to install Debian Sid easily. Morphix, as the name suggests, was originally derived from Knoppix but it also sported some GUI system configuration tools that its developer had ported from Red Hat.
IIRC, there was also another Knoppix-derivative before Kanotix, called Gnoppix, that came with GNOME. But I'm not sure if Gnoppix was actually installable and I never used it, so I don't have any first-hand details about it. However, I have a vague recollection that Canonical might have hired the Gnoppix developer when Ubuntu was first started, which would make the current Ubuntu live-cd a descendant of Gnoppix (and Knoppix).







Member since:
2006-01-01
The first major distro to do this (a single CD hybrid live / install edition) was Mepis.
Knoppix did this long, long before Mepis.