To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
make them too consistent (similar in perspective, color, brightness, shape) and they become basically indistinguishable
That's what I said about the new Krita icons:
http://www.koffice.org/krita/pics/bala_krita1.6.png
The response was that they look classier or more consistent or something. Never mind that there are no color hints for distinguishing between the icons anymore.
Previous setr:
http://www.koffice.org/krita/pics/july06.png
Separation between icons doesn't have to be about Color. The actual geometry alone can make all the difference in the world. The new icons for Krita are more pleasing on the eyes and you can distinguish quickly. Now if they can add some color/contrast on them to indicate what one is to expect when using them [where necessary] then all the better.
Application specific task/action icons are more susceptible to geometry needing to be unique than application startup icon needing to be both color and geometry needing to be unique but consistent in balance wrt to the rest of the desktop.
Old NeXTSTEP addressed this with the consistent gray border around their icons. Borderless icons opened up a world of distraction forcing one to really pick steady color themes in the background and letting the foreground standout wrt to the unique geometry of the icon.
Photorealistic icons have been overdone and used to compensate for an inconsistent look n' feel.





Member since:
2006-07-30
The whole consistency thing is a double edged sword:
Make your icons too inconsistent and the whole thing looks like a mess, make them too consistent (similar in perspective, color, brightness, shape) and they become basically indistinguishable, especially if they are rather small.
Friends think my icons look like one big mess but if they were more similar I would struggle to actually see the differences between them. So I guess it's different strokes for different folks again.
At least I would choose messy and inconsistent icons over icons that all look the same any day.
But that may result from my eyes which are not all that good ;-)
Nice article, anyway. I didn't know how much thought people put into icons. Although I must say I liked the first part of this series better. But that may be just me and let's not start to interpolate using just two values ;-)