Linked by Thom Holwerda on Wed 26th Mar 2008 21:30 UTC, submitted by ohxten
Thread beginning with comment 306821
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
To view parent comment, click here.
To read all comments associated with this story, please click here.
I think Linux started his OS as another hobby OS too.
True, but OSes were a lot simpler back then. It is just about impossible for a new OS to emerge today and be successful. The work required is just too much.
Especially when the advantage of the new OS is simply speed. That's not an advantage. It's just a symptom of being incomplete.
Nothing wrong with hobby/educational OSes, but lets not kid ourselves as to what they are.
I think Linux started his OS as another hobby OS too.
Sure, but now the existence of Linux raise the barrier of entry to make another useful OS..
When Linus started Minix wasn't really Free and there was a lawsuit against BSD and no major Free OS existed..
We do not know whether one of these "experiments" will grow up as a mainstream OS.
No, but we do know that from the kernel POV being able to provide something to users that the hundreds of kernel developers working on Linux cannot replicate is very difficult, except for a totally different design (like L4 or EROS for example).
And from the userspace either you provide a POSIX layer and you look very much like a Linux distribution which makes it hard to interest users or you don't and you don't have much software..
That said if Haiku/Syllable starts to gain traction, perharps this will motivate other OS dev to improvement for desktop usage..







Member since:
2007-10-17
It seems to be a hobby OS. If you've ever checked out osdev there are hundreds, if not thousands of hobby OS's that follow POSIX's ideas. Most of them never make it past the initial development stage, and ones like this are the result of a lot of determined work, and are quite rare.
Their point is usually a combination of study and or accomplishment.